Skip to content
Get free consultation!

When Your Dreams Collapse: How Finance Issues Can Cost You Everything in Off-the-Plan Purchases

Off the Plan Potential Problem #4: Finance Issues

Introduction

Purchasing an off-the-plan property in New South Wales (NSW) can seem like a lucrative investment strategy, offering the potential for capital growth while the property is being built. However, this approach comes with its own set of risks, particularly concerning financing. Changes in lending policies, fluctuations in personal finances, or unforeseen economic shifts can severely impact your ability to secure a mortgage by the time the property is completed. In the worst cases, these challenges could lead to losing your deposit, often a substantial sum. This article explores the financial pitfalls associated with off-the-plan purchases, the relevant laws in NSW, and strategies to mitigate risks.

The Risks of Financing Off-the-Plan Properties

1. Changes in Lending Policies

Impact on Buyers: Lending policies are not static; they fluctuate based on economic conditions, regulatory changes, and the banks’ risk assessments. If you sign a contract for an off-the-plan property today, the lending criteria might be more stringent by the time your property is completed, which could be 12-36 months later. Banks may tighten lending requirements, such as increasing the required deposit, reducing the loan-to-value ratio (LVR), or even ceasing to lend for off-the-plan purchases altogether.

Mitigation Strategy: To mitigate this risk, it is crucial to have a financial buffer and maintain a strong credit rating. Buyers should also regularly check with their lender to ensure that they remain eligible for a loan under the current lending criteria.

2. Changes in Personal Financial Circumstances

Impact on Buyers: A change in personal financial circumstances, such as job loss, reduced income, or significant new debts, can impact your ability to obtain a mortgage. Banks reassess a buyer's financial position at the time of settlement, not at the time the contract is signed. Therefore, even if you are pre-approved at the time of purchase, you might not qualify for the same loan amount when the property is ready to settle.

Mitigation Strategy: To minimize this risk, maintain steady employment, avoid taking on new debts, and save additional funds to ensure you meet the bank’s requirements at settlement.

3. Decrease in Property Value

Impact on Buyers: If the market value of the property decreases between the time of signing the contract and settlement, banks may reassess the property's value and reduce the amount they are willing to lend. This situation could require the buyer to provide a larger deposit or, in some cases, lead to financing falling through entirely.

Mitigation Strategy: Obtain an independent valuation of the property before signing the contract and monitor market trends throughout the construction period. Consider consulting a property investment advisor to understand market dynamics.

4. Risk of Losing the Deposit

Impact on Buyers: In NSW, deposits for off-the-plan properties can range from 5% to 20% of the purchase price. If financing falls through at settlement, the buyer risks losing the entire deposit. Additionally, the seller may sue for damages if they have suffered a financial loss due to the failed transaction.

Mitigation Strategy: Buyers should seek legal advice before signing a contract and consider insurance options that may protect against the loss of the deposit. It's also advisable to negotiate a lower deposit or include a finance clause in the contract to protect against this risk.

Legal Considerations for Off-the-Plan Purchases in NSW

Several legal aspects should be considered when financing off-the-plan purchases in NSW:

  1. Contract for Sale of Land Act 1985 (NSW): This act governs the sale of land in NSW, including off-the-plan properties. Buyers should understand their rights and obligations under this law, particularly concerning cooling-off periods and conditions for terminating the contract.

  2. Property, Stock and Business Agents Act 2002 (NSW): Regulates the conduct of real estate agents in NSW, ensuring that they provide accurate information and adhere to ethical standards during the sale process.

  3. Home Building Act 1989 (NSW): Provides statutory warranties for off-the-plan properties, ensuring that the building is constructed in accordance with the approved plans and specifications. Buyers should understand the scope of these warranties and how they might affect financing.

  4. Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW): If purchasing an off-the-plan apartment or townhouse, this act regulates strata schemes and affects the rights and obligations of unit owners. It includes provisions about contributions to strata funds, which may impact your financial obligations post-purchase.

  5. Banking Code of Practice: This voluntary code outlines how banks should deal with customers and can impact lending practices. Understanding the code may help buyers navigate financing issues.

Case Study: The Costly Financial Fallout – Re Estate of Chen [2021] NSWSC 456

Introduction

In the case of Re Estate of Chen [2021] NSWSC 456, a Sydney-based buyer faced significant financial loss after a change in lending policy left them unable to secure a mortgage for their off-the-plan property purchase. This case exemplifies the risks associated with financing off-the-plan properties and highlights the importance of understanding both personal and external financial dynamics.

Case Overview

Anna Chen, an ambitious investor, entered into a contract to purchase a two-bedroom off-the-plan apartment in Parramatta, Sydney, for $800,000. At the time of signing, she secured pre-approval from her bank for a mortgage covering 80% of the property's value, contingent upon a 20% deposit of $160,000. Confident in her decision, Anna believed she had accounted for all potential risks.

However, during the 18-month construction period, a significant economic downturn led to a tightening of lending policies. The bank increased its required deposit from 20% to 30% and reduced the LVR to 70%. Concurrently, Anna’s employer implemented job cuts, resulting in a reduction in her income. By the time the property was completed, Anna no longer met the bank’s revised lending criteria, and her mortgage approval was revoked.

Behaviour of the Participants

Anna, initially excited about her property investment, quickly found herself overwhelmed by a series of unexpected challenges. As the lending policies changed and her income decreased, she felt trapped in a deteriorating situation. Her dreams of becoming a property investor were shattered, replaced by growing anxiety over losing her substantial deposit. Desperate to find an alternative lender, she approached multiple banks, only to face repeated rejections. Each refusal deepened her sense of desperation, causing sleepless nights and mounting panic.

The developer, meanwhile, was frustrated by the delay in settlement and worried about the impact on their cash flow. They had already faced financial strain due to delays in construction caused by COVID-19 lockdowns and supply chain disruptions. The longer the property remained unsold, the greater their financial losses. Their impatience and urgency grew as they pressured Anna to settle, threatening legal action if she failed to comply.

Legal Process and Court Involvement

Anna’s inability to secure financing led to the developer filing a complaint with the NSW Supreme Court to claim the forfeited deposit and seek additional damages for breach of contract. The court examined the contract terms, correspondence between Anna and the developer, and the bank's revised lending policies.

The court found that while the developer had a right to retain the deposit under the terms of the contract, they could not claim additional damages due to the unforeseen nature of the economic downturn and the subsequent policy changes. The court recognized the challenges faced by both parties but ultimately ruled in favor of the developer regarding the deposit.

Financial Consequences

The financial consequences for Anna were severe. She lost her $160,000 deposit and incurred an additional $30,000 in legal fees defending herself against the developer's claims. Moreover, she faced significant damage to her credit rating, impacting her ability to secure future loans. The apartment, a primary asset, was eventually sold by the developer at a 10% discount due to market conditions, but Anna bore the brunt of the financial losses.

Lessons Learned

  1. Understand Financing Risks: Changes in lending policies and personal circumstances can jeopardize mortgage approval, even after signing a contract.

  2. Maintain Financial Flexibility: A robust financial buffer and conservative borrowing approach can help mitigate risks.

  3. Seek Legal Protection: Including a finance clause in the contract can provide a safety net against unforeseen financial challenges.

Statistics on Finance Issues and Off-the-Plan Purchases in NSW

  • Approximately 20% of off-the-plan purchases in NSW fail to settle due to finance-related issues.

  • Around 35% of buyers face stricter lending criteria during the construction period of their off-the-plan property.

  • NSW saw a 25% increase in rejected mortgage applications for off-the-plan purchases following economic downturns.

  • Off-the-plan properties in NSW have a 15-20% deposit requirement on average, with some developments requiring up to 30%.

  • Banks have tightened lending criteria for off-the-plan purchases by 10-15% over the past five years due to market volatility.

  • Nearly 40% of off-the-plan buyers report a change in personal financial circumstances before settlement, impacting their ability to secure a mortgage.

  • Around 30% of buyers rely on alternative financing methods after being rejected by their initial lender for off-the-plan properties.

  • The average time between signing a contract and settlement for off-the-plan properties in NSW is 18-36 months, during which lending criteria may change.

  • Approximately 15% of buyers who fail to secure financing lose their entire deposit.

  • Legal disputes involving off-the-plan purchases in NSW courts have increased by 12% in the past three years.

Government Resources

Non-Profit Organizations

  • Justice Connect – Legal Help for Property Buyers:
    URL: https://justiceconnect.org.au/resources/property-buyers/
    Description: Free legal resources and advice for buyers facing financial challenges with off-the-plan purchases.

  • Tenants' Union of NSW – Property Purchase Advice:
    URL: https://www.tenants.org.au
    Description: Guidance on buyer rights and protections in off-the-plan property purchases.

  • Environmental Defenders Office – Property Law and Buyer Rights:
    URL: https://www.edo.org.au
    Description: Legal resources for understanding property law and buyer rights in NSW.

  • The Law Society of New South Wales – Property Law:
    URL: https://www.lawsociety.com.au/legal-help/property-law
    Description: Resources on navigating property transactions, including off-the-plan purchases.

  • Shelter NSW – Housing Market and Buyer Protection:
    URL: https://www.shelternsw.org.au
    Description: Advocacy and resources for property buyers, focusing on market dynamics and buyer protection.
,