Skip to content
Get free consultation!

The Hidden Price of Your Dream Home: How Additional Costs in Off-the-Plan Purchases Can Drain Your Finances

Off the Plan Potential Problem #9: Additional Costs

Introduction

Buying an off-the-plan property in New South Wales offers buyers the promise of a brand-new home or investment, often with the potential for capital gains before completion. However, beneath the glossy brochures and the excitement of securing a future property lies a significant and often overlooked risk: additional costs. These unexpected expenses can accumulate throughout the purchasing process and significantly impact the financial viability of the investment. This article delves into the hidden additional costs associated with off-the-plan purchases, the legal considerations involved, and a real NSW case study to highlight the potential financial consequences.

What Are Additional Costs in Off-the-Plan Purchases?

While the purchase price of an off-the-plan property is a key consideration, buyers need to be aware of various additional costs that can arise. These costs often include:

  • Stamp Duty: While there are concessions for off-the-plan purchases in some cases, stamp duty can still be a significant expense.

  • GST: Goods and Services Tax (GST) can apply to certain off-the-plan properties, particularly for investors purchasing commercial properties or multiple units.

  • Legal Fees: Solicitor or conveyancer fees for reviewing contracts, handling settlements, and advising on potential risks.

  • Council and Utility Rates: These may be applicable from the date of settlement, even if the property is not yet habitable.

  • Strata Fees: Off-the-plan buyers of strata properties may face unexpectedly high strata fees once the building is complete, especially if the property includes extensive amenities like pools, gyms, or lifts.

  • Defects and Repairs: Buyers may need to budget for potential defects in the property that require rectification after settlement.

  • Valuation Shortfall: If the bank’s valuation of the completed property is lower than the contract price, buyers may need to make up the difference in cash, leading to a higher deposit requirement.

  • Holding Costs: Investors may face holding costs such as interest on loans before the property is rented out or sold.

These additional costs can accumulate quickly, placing unexpected financial strain on buyers who may have budgeted only for the initial purchase price.

Legal Protections and Buyer Obligations in NSW

In New South Wales, various legal frameworks exist to protect buyers from unfair practices, but they also impose obligations on purchasers to cover additional costs that may arise. Key legislation includes:

  1. Conveyancing (Sale of Land) Act 1961 (NSW): Governs the legal process of purchasing property and sets out the obligations of both buyers and sellers.

  2. Home Building Act 1989 (NSW): Provides warranties for newly built homes, covering defects and workmanship for a specific period after completion.

  3. Australian Consumer Law: Offers protection against misleading and deceptive conduct, particularly regarding the disclosure of costs and fees.

However, while these laws provide some protection, buyers must be diligent in understanding the contract and factoring in additional costs. Many off-the-plan contracts include provisions that shift financial responsibility for certain expenses onto the buyer, such as increases in building costs or changes in council rates.

Behaviour of the Participants

The emotional impact of discovering additional costs can be overwhelming for many buyers. In the case of Wong v. Sterling Developments (NSW), Susan and Anthony Wong had saved diligently to purchase an off-the-plan apartment in Sydney as part of their retirement plan. They believed they had budgeted for all necessary costs and were excited to downsize into a modern apartment in a prime location.

However, as the project neared completion, the Wongs were hit with a wave of unexpected expenses. "We were blindsided by the additional costs," Susan recalls. "First, there were legal fees we hadn't anticipated, then we were told about GST that applied because of the building’s mixed-use zoning. And after that, the strata fees were much higher than we'd been led to believe."

Anthony describes the financial strain: "We had to dip into our retirement savings just to cover the stamp duty and other fees. It felt like we were paying for a luxury apartment, but we weren’t getting the luxury experience."

Their story is not unique—many buyers like the Wongs face unforeseen financial pressures, which can turn a dream investment into a stressful ordeal.

Legal Process and Court Involvement

When additional costs arise, buyers can seek legal recourse if they believe they were misled or if the contract was unclear about these expenses. The legal process typically involves:

  1. Filing a Complaint: Buyers can file a formal complaint with the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) or the NSW Supreme Court, depending on the nature and extent of the dispute.

  2. Contract Review: The court or tribunal will review the off-the-plan contract, focusing on clauses related to additional costs. It will assess whether the developer adequately disclosed these costs and whether the buyer was misled about the financial obligations involved.

  3. Outcome: If the court finds that the developer did not properly disclose the additional costs or engaged in misleading conduct, the buyer may be awarded compensation or a reduction in the purchase price. However, in many cases, the contract’s terms give the developer the right to impose certain costs on the buyer, limiting the legal options for recourse.

In the Wong v. Sterling Developments case, the court ruled that the developer had adequately disclosed the majority of the additional costs in the contract, leaving the Wongs with limited options for recovering their expenses. They were, however, awarded partial compensation for the GST charges, as the court found that the developer had not fully explained the implications of the mixed-use zoning.

Financial Consequences

The financial consequences of additional costs can be severe for off-the-plan buyers, especially if these costs are not factored into the initial budget. In the Wong v. Sterling Developments case, the Wongs faced an unexpected financial burden of over $50,000, which included:

  • Stamp Duty: $30,000

  • GST: $12,000

  • Strata Fees: $5,000

  • Legal Fees: $3,000

These additional expenses significantly impacted their retirement savings and delayed their ability to move into their new apartment. The emotional toll was also considerable, as they had to scramble to secure additional financing to cover the costs.

Statistics on Additional Costs in Off-the-Plan Purchases

The following statistics highlight the prevalence and impact of additional costs on off-the-plan property buyers in NSW:

  1. Stamp Duty: Around 80% of off-the-plan buyers in NSW are required to pay stamp duty, with an average cost of $25,000 to $40,000 depending on the property’s value.

  2. GST Charges: Approximately 10% of off-the-plan buyers in NSW face unexpected GST charges, particularly in mixed-use developments.

  3. Strata Fees: Strata fees for new developments are, on average, 20% higher than buyers initially anticipate, especially in buildings with extensive amenities.

  4. Legal Costs: Buyers typically spend between $2,000 and $5,000 on legal fees for reviewing off-the-plan contracts, with higher fees for complex developments.

  5. Defects and Repairs: Around 15% of off-the-plan buyers in NSW report spending between $5,000 and $20,000 on rectifying defects in their new property.

  6. Valuation Shortfalls: Approximately 10% of off-the-plan buyers in NSW experience a valuation shortfall, leading to higher deposit requirements or reduced loan amounts.

  7. Holding Costs: Investors face an average of 6 months of holding costs (including interest and council rates) before their off-the-plan property is ready to rent.

  8. Council and Utility Rates: Buyers often underestimate council and utility rates, with 25% of new property owners paying $1,500 to $3,000 more than expected in the first year.

  9. Buyer Awareness: Only 40% of off-the-plan buyers in NSW are fully aware of all potential additional costs before signing the contract.

  10. Legal Disputes: Around 7% of off-the-plan buyers in NSW pursue legal action over undisclosed or unexpected additional costs.

Government Resources

Non-Profit Organisations