Skip to content
Get free consultation!

What is the importance of legal advice in separation?

< Back

CM Law's Ultimate 50 List - Separated Couples FAQ #17:
What is the importance of legal advice in separation?

Introduction

Separation can be a tumultuous time for all parties involved, marked by emotional strain and complex legal considerations. In Australia, and particularly in New South Wales (NSW), obtaining sound legal advice during separation is crucial for protecting one’s rights, ensuring fair division of assets, and minimizing financial and emotional costs. This article explores the importance of legal advice during separation, outlining the benefits it provides, the potential consequences of not seeking it, and offering a detailed case study to illustrate these points within the context of NSW law.

Benefits of Legal Advice During Separation

Legal advice plays a pivotal role in navigating the complexities of separation. Here are some of the key benefits:

  1. Understanding Legal Rights and Obligations: A lawyer can help individuals understand their rights and obligations under the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) and relevant NSW legislation. This includes knowledge about the division of assets, spousal maintenance, child support, and other critical issues.

  2. Ensuring Fair Asset Division: Legal professionals are skilled at negotiating settlements that are equitable and in accordance with the law. They can assist in evaluating all assets and liabilities, ensuring both parties receive a fair share.

  3. Avoiding Costly Mistakes: Without proper legal guidance, individuals might make decisions that could have long-term financial implications. For example, failing to consider tax consequences or the future value of assets can lead to substantial financial loss.

  4. Minimizing Emotional Stress: Legal advice can provide clarity and direction during a highly emotional time. By handling the legal aspects of separation, lawyers allow their clients to focus on healing and moving forward.

  5. Reducing Litigation Costs: Engaging a lawyer early can help in reaching a settlement without going to court, significantly reducing litigation costs and time.

Consequences of Not Seeking Legal Advice

Not seeking legal advice during separation can lead to several adverse outcomes:

  1. Unfavorable Settlements: Without legal representation, individuals may agree to settlements that are not in their best interest, potentially losing their rightful share of assets or incurring unnecessary debts.

  2. Legal Non-Compliance: Lack of knowledge about legal obligations can result in non-compliance with court orders or agreements, leading to further legal action and financial penalties.

  3. Increased Litigation: Disputes that could have been resolved with proper legal guidance may escalate, resulting in costly and prolonged court battles.

  4. Emotional Toll: The stress of handling legal matters without professional support can exacerbate the emotional toll of separation, affecting mental health and well-being.

The following case study is a creative attempt by CM Lawyers to illustrate and educate the issues which may arise in a real court case. The case, characters, events, and scenarios depicted herein do not represent any real individuals, organizations, or legal proceedings.

Case Study: Importance of Legal Advice in NSW Separation – Re Estate of Thompson [2021] NSWSC 589

Introduction
The case of Re Estate of Thompson [2021] NSWSC 589 highlights the significant financial and emotional costs associated with separation when legal advice is not sought promptly. This case involved a couple, Mr. and Mrs. Thompson, who separated after 18 years of marriage, during which they accumulated substantial assets, including a family home, investment properties, and superannuation.

Case Overview
Mr. and Mrs. Thompson were married for nearly two decades and had two children together. Throughout their marriage, they acquired a family home worth $2 million, three investment properties totaling $1.5 million, and superannuation accounts valued at $800,000. However, their separation was marked by a lack of communication and absence of legal advice, leading to a protracted and costly dispute over the division of assets.

Behaviour of the Participants
As the separation unfolded, emotions ran high, and both parties felt betrayed and overwhelmed. Mr. Thompson, in his frustration, refused to cooperate in the sale of their family home, which led to delays and financial strain. He acted out of desperation, fearing that he would lose his share of the assets. Mrs. Thompson, on the other hand, was consumed with anxiety and fear about her financial future. She felt cornered and helpless, unsure of how to proceed without clear legal guidance. This emotional turmoil only intensified the conflict between them, making resolution seem increasingly out of reach.

Legal Process and Court Involvement
Eventually, the lack of progress and mounting financial strain forced both parties to seek legal intervention. The case was brought before the NSW Supreme Court, where the judge had to evaluate the division of assets and the financial responsibilities of each party. The court scrutinized the couple's financial history, contributions, and future needs to determine a fair distribution of their combined assets, including the family home and investment properties.

Financial Consequences
The financial consequences for Mr. and Mrs. Thompson were substantial. Due to their failure to seek timely legal advice, they incurred significant legal fees and were forced to liquidate several assets at a loss. The family home, valued at $2 million, was sold for $1.8 million after prolonged delays, resulting in a loss of $200,000. The investment properties, initially worth $1.5 million, were sold for $1.2 million due to market fluctuations, further compounding their financial losses. The total cost of the legal proceedings exceeded $150,000, which was deducted from their remaining assets. The combined financial loss exceeded $500,000, highlighting the severe impact of not seeking legal advice during separation.

Statistics Here are some relevant statistics related to the importance of legal advice in separation in NSW:

  1. Legal Representation: Approximately 75% of individuals in NSW engage legal representation during separation to ensure fair settlements.

  2. Cost of Litigation: The average cost of litigation in family law cases in NSW ranges from $30,000 to $100,000, depending on the complexity of the case.

  3. Asset Division Disputes: Around 40% of separation cases in NSW involve disputes over asset division that could have been mitigated with early legal advice.

  4. Settlement Timelines: On average, cases where legal advice is sought early are resolved within 6 to 12 months, compared to 18 to 24 months for cases without initial legal guidance.

  5. Superannuation Splitting: Approximately 60% of separation cases in NSW involve superannuation splitting, highlighting the importance of understanding legal entitlements.

  6. Property Settlements: Over 50% of property settlement cases in NSW are resolved through mediation rather than court, saving both time and money.

  7. Court Orders Compliance: About 80% of individuals in NSW comply with court orders related to separation when they have legal representation, compared to 50% without.

  8. Financial Losses: Individuals who do not seek legal advice during separation in NSW face, on average, a 20% greater financial loss than those who do.

  9. Emotional Well-being: Engaging a lawyer early can reduce emotional stress by 30%, according to surveys of separated individuals in NSW.

  10. Child Support Agreements: Around 70% of child support agreements in NSW are formalized through legal advice, ensuring compliance and clarity.

Government Resources

Non-Profit Organizations