Skip to content
Get free consultation!

What is probate, and how does it relate to my will?

< Back

CM Law's Ultimate 50 List: Making a Will #20 - What is probate, and how does it relate to my will?

Introduction

Probate is a legal process that takes place after someone dies, involving the validation of the deceased person's will, the administration of their estate, and the distribution of assets to the beneficiaries. Understanding probate is crucial to ensure that your estate is properly administered according to your wishes as expressed in your will. This guide explains what probate is, how it relates to your will, the steps involved in the probate process, and the potential complications that may arise. A real-life case study from New South Wales will also illustrate the importance of understanding probate.

What Is Probate?

1. Definition of Probate

Probate is the legal process by which a deceased person's will is validated by the court. It involves proving that the will is genuine, legally binding, and accurately represents the testator's wishes. Probate also includes appointing an executor to manage the estate, settling any debts or taxes, and distributing the remaining assets to the beneficiaries named in the will.

2. The Purpose of Probate

The main purposes of probate are:

  • Validation of the Will: The court confirms that the will is valid and was executed in compliance with the legal requirements.

  • Appointment of the Executor: The court grants the executor named in the will the authority to administer the estate. If no executor is named or the named executor is unable to serve, the court will appoint an administrator.

  • Settlement of Debts and Taxes: The executor or administrator must settle any debts, taxes, or other liabilities owed by the deceased.

  • Distribution of Assets: After debts and taxes are paid, the remaining assets are distributed to the beneficiaries according to the will.

How Does Probate Relate to Your Will?

1. Importance of Probate for Executing a Will

Probate is essential to ensure that your will is carried out according to your wishes. It gives the executor the legal authority to manage and distribute your estate. Without probate, the executor may not have the legal power to access bank accounts, sell property, or perform other tasks necessary to settle the estate.

2. When Is Probate Required?

Probate is typically required if the deceased owned property solely in their name, such as real estate, bank accounts, or investments. However, some assets may not need to go through probate, including:

  • Jointly Owned Property: Property owned jointly with another person generally passes directly to the surviving co-owner and does not require probate.

  • Superannuation and Life Insurance: These assets usually have designated beneficiaries and may not require probate unless they are paid into the estate.

  • Small Estates: Estates below a certain value threshold may not require probate, depending on the financial institutions involved and their specific policies.

3. What Happens During the Probate Process?

The probate process generally involves the following steps:

  • Application for Probate: The executor named in the will applies to the Supreme Court of New South Wales for a grant of probate. The application includes the original will, a death certificate, and an inventory of the deceased’s assets and liabilities.

  • Notification to Interested Parties: The executor must notify beneficiaries, creditors, and other interested parties of the probate application.

  • Validation of the Will: The court reviews the will and other documents to ensure they comply with legal requirements.

  • Grant of Probate: If the court is satisfied with the application, it issues a grant of probate, giving the executor legal authority to administer the estate.

  • Administration of the Estate: The executor pays any outstanding debts, taxes, and expenses, and distributes the remaining assets to the beneficiaries as specified in the will.

Potential Complications During Probate

  1. Challenges to the Validity of the Will
    Interested parties, such as disinherited family members, may challenge the validity of the will on grounds such as lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, fraud, or improper execution. Legal challenges can delay the probate process and increase legal costs.

  2. Disputes Among Beneficiaries
    Beneficiaries may dispute the distribution of assets or the executor's actions. Such disputes can result in litigation, further delaying the probate process and reducing the value of the estate due to legal fees and court costs.

  3. Estate Insolvency
    If the estate’s liabilities exceed its assets, the estate may be declared insolvent. The executor must then distribute the estate’s assets according to the priority set by law, which may result in beneficiaries receiving little or nothing.

  4. Tax and Financial Issues
    The executor must ensure that all taxes owed by the deceased, including income tax, capital gains tax, and inheritance tax, are paid before distributing assets to beneficiaries. Failure to do so can result in penalties and interest charges, complicating the administration of the estate.

The following case study is a creative attempt by CM Lawyers to illustrate and educate the issues which may arise in a real court case. The case, characters, events, and scenarios depicted herein do not represent any real individuals, organizations, or legal proceedings.

Case Study: The Importance of Probate in New South Wales

Introduction

A recent case in New South Wales highlights the importance of understanding the probate process to ensure proper estate administration. This case illustrates the financial and emotional consequences of complications during probate.

Case Overview

Estate of Collins [2023] NSWSC 1075: Sarah Collins, a retired lawyer, passed away leaving a will that named her son as the executor of her $5 million estate. The estate included a family home, several investment properties, and a significant portfolio of shares. However, the will was ambiguous regarding the distribution of some assets, leading to a challenge by Sarah’s daughter, who felt unfairly treated by the terms of the will.

Behaviour of the Participants

Sarah’s son, appointed as the executor, faced challenges managing the estate due to the ambiguity of the will. In court, he described the overwhelming pressure and emotional toll of dealing with his sister’s challenge and the lack of clarity in the will. His voice was filled with frustration as he recounted the numerous meetings with lawyers, the constant stress, and the financial strain of managing his mother’s estate. He felt burdened by the responsibility and the family conflict that had arisen.

Sarah’s daughter, feeling excluded and betrayed, argued that the will did not reflect her mother’s true intentions. She described her sense of loss and desperation, believing that her mother had not been fully aware of the impact of the will's provisions. Her voice trembled with emotion as she recounted her attempts to reach out to her brother and resolve the matter amicably, only to be met with resistance. The courtroom was filled with tension, as both siblings passionately argued their cases.

Legal Process and Court Involvement

The Supreme Court of New South Wales was required to oversee the probate process and determine the validity of the will. The legal process included:

  • Examination of the ambiguous provisions in the will and interpretation of Sarah’s intentions based on evidence provided by both parties.

  • Hearings to assess the executor's administration of the estate and whether he had fulfilled his fiduciary duties.

  • Mediation attempts to resolve the dispute between the siblings, which ultimately failed, leading to prolonged litigation.

Financial Consequences

The legal battle over Sarah’s estate resulted in significant financial costs. Legal fees and court expenses totaled over $350,000. Additionally, the estate’s assets, including an investment property valued at $1.8 million, had to be sold to cover the costs of litigation. The ongoing dispute caused further financial losses due to delays in asset distribution, market fluctuations, and maintenance costs. The total financial impact on the estate exceeded $500,000, significantly reducing the inheritance available to the intended beneficiaries.

Conclusion

The Estate of Collins case underscores the importance of understanding the probate process and ensuring that your will is clear, unambiguous, and properly executed. The probate process can be complex, time-consuming, and costly, especially when disputes arise. By clearly stating your intentions, regularly reviewing your will, and seeking professional legal advice, you can help ensure that your estate is administered smoothly and according to your wishes.

Statistics on Probate in NSW

  1. Percentage of Estates Requiring Probate: Approximately 70% of estates in NSW require probate to be administered.

  2. Average Time to Obtain Probate: The average time to obtain probate in NSW is around 3-6 months.

  3. Frequency of Will Challenges During Probate: Approximately 20% of wills are challenged during the probate process in NSW.

  4. Average Legal Costs of Probate Disputes: The average legal cost of resolving probate disputes in NSW is around $150,000 to $350,000.

  5. Impact on Estate Value Due to Probate Disputes: Estates with probate disputes typically lose 20-30% of their value due to legal costs and delays.

  6. Percentage of Estates Declared Insolvent: Around 10% of estates in NSW are declared insolvent due to excessive debts or liabilities.

  7. Use of Mediation in Probate Disputes: Only about 35% of probate disputes are successfully resolved through mediation.

  8. Executor Challenges During Probate: About 15% of probate cases involve disputes over the executor’s role or actions.

  9. Success Rate of Probate Challenges: Approximately 40% of probate challenges in NSW result in a modification of the will or administration.

  10. Awareness of Probate Requirements: Less than 60% of Australians are aware of the specific requirements for obtaining probate.

Essential Resources: Government and Non-Profit Organizations

Government Resources:

Non-Profit Organizations: