Skip to content
Get free consultation!

Unlocking the Past: How Property History Can Make or Break Your Investment

CM Law's Ultimate List: The top 50 FAQs on Buying a Residential Investment Property #46. Property History

Introduction

When purchasing a residential investment property in Australia, understanding the property's history is crucial for making informed decisions. The property's past can reveal valuable insights about its condition, ownership, market value, and potential risks, all of which can impact the property's investment potential. In New South Wales (NSW), property history can also provide clues about zoning changes, previous renovations, or legal disputes, allowing investors to better assess the long-term prospects of the property. This guide explores the key aspects of property history that investors need to investigate and why this information is essential for safeguarding your investment.

Key Aspects of Property History to Investigate:

Previous Ownership and Title History:

The ownership history of a property can provide insights into the stability of the property’s value and highlight potential legal issues. In NSW, the Land Titles Office maintains a detailed record of past and present ownership through title deeds. Investors can access these records to ensure that there are no unresolved ownership disputes, claims of adverse possession, or other legal challenges that could impact the property's title.

By reviewing the property’s title history, investors can verify that the seller has the legal right to sell the property. This step is particularly important when purchasing properties with long ownership chains, as previous owners may not have properly resolved boundary disputes, unpaid taxes, or legal claims.

Past Market Transactions and Price Trends:

Understanding how the property’s value has fluctuated over time is critical for assessing its future investment potential. Reviewing the property’s sale history can provide insights into its market performance, including periods of significant price increases or declines. In NSW, investors can access property transaction data through sources such as CoreLogic and NSW Land Registry Services, which offer detailed information on past sales prices.

If the property has seen frequent sales or significant price drops, it could indicate underlying issues that may affect future value. Additionally, properties that have steadily appreciated over time, especially in high-demand areas, can offer reassurance that the property is likely to continue performing well in the long term.

Renovations and Building Approvals:

A property’s renovation history is essential for understanding its structural integrity and compliance with building codes. In NSW, major renovations and extensions require council approval under the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979. Investors can review building permits and approvals to verify whether previous renovations were completed legally and whether any outstanding permits are still active.

If a property has undergone extensive renovations without the necessary approvals, investors could face significant legal and financial challenges, including fines, demolition orders, or costly repairs. By ensuring that all renovations are legally documented and approved, investors can avoid unexpected expenses and future legal disputes.

Zoning Changes and Land Use History:

Zoning regulations can significantly impact the value and development potential of a property. By reviewing the property’s zoning history, investors can determine whether the land has been reclassified for different uses over time. For example, properties that were once zoned for low-density residential use may have been reclassified for higher-density development, offering new opportunities for investors.

In NSW, zoning information is available through local councils and the NSW Planning Portal. Understanding the property’s zoning history can also help investors avoid purchasing properties that are subject to restrictive zoning or environmental overlays, which may limit future development plans.

Legal Disputes and Litigation:

Properties with a history of legal disputes, such as boundary disagreements, title issues, or building defects, can pose significant risks to investors. NSW court records provide information on past and ongoing litigation involving a property, which can help investors identify potential legal risks before making a purchase.

For example, if a property was previously involved in a legal dispute over a boundary line, investors may face challenges when attempting to develop or sell the property in the future. Ensuring that all legal disputes have been resolved and documented can provide peace of mind and protect the investment from future complications.

Behaviour of the Participants:

Many investors rush into property purchases without fully investigating the property's history, only to encounter costly issues down the line. One Sydney-based investor purchased a property without realizing that it had been subject to multiple legal disputes over boundary lines. After attempting to develop the property, the investor faced expensive legal fees and delays, ultimately reducing the profitability of the investment.

In contrast, another investor in Newcastle conducted thorough due diligence on a property’s past transactions, building permits, and zoning changes. Armed with this knowledge, the investor was able to capitalize on the property’s potential for future development, achieving strong capital growth.

Legal Process and Court Involvement:

Legal disputes over property history often involve claims of undisclosed defects, title issues, or unresolved zoning conflicts. In the case of Williams v Goldline Developments [2020] NSWLEC 1142, the buyer sued the seller for failing to disclose a previous legal dispute over the property’s boundary lines. The dispute had not been resolved, leading to delays in the buyer’s plans to develop the property.

The court ruled in favor of the buyer, ordering the seller to pay compensation for the additional legal fees and delays in development. This case highlights the importance of reviewing all aspects of a property’s history, particularly when legal disputes are involved.

Financial Consequences:

In the Williams v Goldline Developments case, the financial impact on the buyer was significant. The buyer faced over $50,000 in legal fees and delays in obtaining development approvals, which further reduced the property’s profitability. The seller, found liable for failing to disclose the dispute, was ordered to pay compensation.

For investors, undisclosed issues related to property history can quickly erode profits. Whether it’s legal disputes, unresolved zoning issues, or undocumented renovations, failing to investigate the property’s history can lead to costly repairs, delays, and legal battles that diminish the return on investment.

Considerations for Investors:

  1. Review Title and Ownership History: Before purchasing an investment property, review the title history to ensure there are no unresolved disputes or legal claims. Verify that the seller has clear ownership of the property.

  2. Analyze Past Sales Trends: Investigate the property’s sales history to assess its market performance over time. Frequent sales or price fluctuations may indicate underlying issues.

  3. Check Building Approvals and Renovations: Ensure that all previous renovations were approved by local councils and comply with building codes. Unapproved renovations can lead to legal and financial risks.

  4. Understand Zoning and Land Use Changes: Review the property’s zoning history to assess its development potential. Properties with favorable zoning changes may offer growth opportunities, while restrictive zoning could limit future plans.

  5. Investigate Legal Disputes: Check for any past or ongoing legal disputes related to the property. Properties involved in litigation may face delays or additional costs that can impact the investment’s profitability.

Statistics:

  1. Title Disputes: 5% of residential properties in NSW have unresolved title disputes, which can delay transactions and development plans (Source: NSW Land Registry Services).

  2. Unapproved Renovations: 10% of properties in NSW have undergone renovations without council approval, leading to potential fines or legal action (Source: NSW Planning Portal).

  3. Price Fluctuations: Properties in Sydney’s inner suburbs have seen an average price increase of 7% per year over the past decade, while properties with frequent sales often show less consistent growth (Source: CoreLogic).

  4. Zoning Changes: 15% of properties in NSW have experienced zoning changes in the past five years, with many being reclassified for higher-density development (Source: NSW Planning Portal).

  5. Litigation Cases: 8% of property-related court cases in NSW involve disputes over boundary lines, title issues, or building approvals (Source: NSW Law Society).

  6. Development Delays: Properties with unresolved legal or zoning disputes experience an average delay of 12-24 months in development approvals (Source: NSW Planning and Environment).

  7. Unresolved Boundary Disputes: 3% of properties in NSW are involved in boundary disputes, which can delay property development or sales (Source: NSW Supreme Court).

  8. Legal Fees: Buyers involved in legal disputes over property history can face legal fees ranging from $30,000 to $100,000, depending on the complexity of the case (Source: NSW Law Society).

  9. Property Value Increase: Properties with favorable zoning changes have experienced a 10-15% increase in value over the past five years (Source: Domain Group).

  10. Building Code Violations: 5% of properties in NSW face building code violations due to unapproved renovations, leading to potential fines or repair costs (Source: NSW Building Commission).

Essential Resources:

Government Resources:

Non-Profit Resources: