Trustees and Probate: Navigating the Responsibilities

< Back

Probate Problem #30: What are the Responsibilities of a Trustee During Probate?

What are the Responsibilities of a Trustee During Probate?

Managing the responsibilities of a trustee during probate is a critical and legally demanding role. A trustee must act with diligence and in accordance with the terms of the trust or will, ensuring that the assets of the estate are protected, managed, and distributed in the best interests of the beneficiaries. Failure to fulfill these duties can lead to significant legal and financial consequences.

Key Responsibilities of a Trustee

1. Preservation of Trust Property Trustees are required to safeguard and preserve the trust property. This includes not only ensuring that assets are appropriately insured but also making strategic decisions about their management. For instance, a trustee must evaluate whether to hold or sell assets, considering market conditions and potential risks. In cases where an asset is losing value, the trustee must act swiftly to sell or reinvest to avoid further depreciation. Additionally, trustees should diversify investments to mitigate risk and ensure long-term growth, adhering to a cautious investment strategy.
2. Fiduciary Duty and Acting in Good Faith The fiduciary duty is the cornerstone of a trustee's responsibilities, demanding that they always act in the best interests of the beneficiaries. Trustees must avoid any conflicts of interest, which means they cannot engage in transactions that could benefit them personally at the expense of the trust. This duty also requires trustees to act impartially, ensuring that no beneficiary is favored over another. Moreover, trustees must maintain transparency in their dealings and be prepared to justify their decisions, especially when they exercise discretionary powers granted by the trust.
3. Administration and Accounting Accurate and thorough record-keeping is crucial for trustees. They must maintain detailed accounts of all transactions, including income, expenses, and distributions related to the trust. This responsibility extends to preparing and filing tax returns, ensuring compliance with all legal requirements. Trustees should also regularly communicate with beneficiaries, providing them with clear and timely reports on the trust’s financial status. Engaging professional accountants or financial advisors can be beneficial to ensure that all financial obligations are met accurately and efficiently.
4. Distributions and Beneficiary Management Trustees are responsible for managing and distributing trust assets in strict accordance with the trust's terms. This includes determining the timing and amount of distributions, which can be complex if the trust includes provisions for minor or incapacitated beneficiaries. Trustees must consider the long-term needs of the beneficiaries, balancing immediate financial needs with future security. In situations where the trust allows for discretionary distributions, trustees must carefully document their decision-making process to avoid disputes. Trustees must also be aware of legal restrictions on early distributions, particularly if the estate is still subject to potential claims from creditors or other parties.
5. Legal Compliance and Seeking Professional Advice Trustees must navigate a complex legal landscape, including state and federal laws that govern trusts and estates. To avoid legal pitfalls, trustees should seek professional legal or financial advice when necessary, particularly in complex situations involving large or diverse estates. This is especially important when trustees are faced with potential litigation from beneficiaries or third parties. By consulting with experts, trustees can ensure that their actions are legally sound and that they are fulfilling their duties in accordance with the trust deed and relevant laws. In cases where a trustee's actions are questioned, having sought and followed professional advice can be a crucial defense.

The following case study is a creative attempt by CM Lawyers to illustrate and educate the issues which may arise in a real court case. The case, characters, events, and scenarios depicted herein do not represent any real individuals, organizations, or legal proceedings.

Case Study: Mismanagement and Its Consequences in New South Wales

Introduction

In the case of Re Estate of Donovan [2021] NSWSC 1048, the consequences of a trustee's failure to properly manage the estate were severe, leading to significant financial losses for the beneficiaries. This case illustrates the critical importance of adhering to fiduciary duties and making informed decisions when managing trust property.

Case Overview

The trustee, who was a close family member of the deceased, was entrusted with managing a substantial estate that included multiple properties and financial assets. Despite the clear terms of the will, the trustee delayed selling a deteriorating property, ignoring professional advice that the market was likely to decline. The property’s value decreased by over $300,000 as the market conditions worsened, resulting in a significant loss to the estate.

Trustee's Mismanagement

The trustee not only failed to act on time but also neglected to obtain necessary insurance for the property. When the property was damaged in a severe storm, the lack of insurance led to additional losses that could have been avoided. Furthermore, the trustee made speculative investments in high-risk shares without consulting a financial advisor, leading to further depletion of the estate's value.

Legal Process and Court Involvement

The beneficiaries, concerned about the diminishing value of the estate and the trustee's apparent neglect, filed a complaint with the NSW Supreme Court. The court examined the trustee’s actions and found that there had been a clear breach of fiduciary duty. The trustee was found to have failed in their obligation to preserve the estate’s assets and act in the best interests of the beneficiaries.

Financial Consequences

The financial impact of the trustee’s mismanagement was substantial. The court ordered the trustee to repay $150,000 to the estate, representing a portion of the losses incurred due to the trustee’s actions. The legal costs associated with the case exceeded $200,000, further reducing the inheritance available to the beneficiaries. In total, the estate’s value was diminished by over $650,000, underscoring the severe consequences of poor estate management.

Conclusion

The Re Estate of Donovan case serves as a stark reminder of the importance of diligence and professionalism in managing an estate. Trustees must act promptly, seek professional advice when needed, and always prioritize the best interests of the beneficiaries. Failure to do so can lead to costly legal battles and a significant reduction in the estate’s value.

Statistics

1. Executor and Trustee Overlap: Approximately 70% of trustees are also named as executors in wills, making it crucial that they fully understand the responsibilities of both roles.
2. Professional Trustee Appointments: In NSW, about 25% of high-value estates appoint professional trustees to manage the estate due to the complexity involved.
3. Trustee Mismanagement Cases: Each year, around 15% of probate cases in NSW involve allegations of trustee mismanagement or breach of fiduciary duty.
4. Legal Costs in Disputes: The average legal cost of disputes involving trustee mismanagement in NSW is approximately $150,000.
5. Asset Depreciation Due to Delays: Estates that experience delays in asset liquidation due to trustee inaction see an average depreciation of 20% in asset value.

Essential Resources: Government and Non-Profit Organizations

Government Resources

1. NSW Government – Wills Probate and Inheritance
   URL: https://www.nsw.gov.au/law-and-justice/wills-probate-and-inheritance
   Provides detailed information on the legal responsibilities of trustees and executors, including guidance on managing and distributing estate assets.
2. NSW Supreme Court – Probate
   URL: https://www.supremecourt.justice.nsw.gov.au/Pages/sco2_probate/probate.aspx
   Offers resources on the probate process, including how trustees can handle complex estates and fulfill their legal duties.
3. Australian Taxation Office – Managing Trusts
   URL: https://www.ato.gov.au/General/Trusts/Managing-trusts/
   Provides information on tax obligations for trustees, including filing requirements and how to handle income and capital gains taxes for trust assets.
4. NSW Trustee & Guardian
   URL: https://www.tag.nsw.gov.au/wills-and-estates/trustees
   Offers services and resources for trustees, including professional trustee services and advice on managing estate assets.
5. ASIC – Running a Trust
   URL: https://asic.gov.au/for-business/your-business/running-a-trust/
   Provides guidance on the legal and financial responsibilities of running a trust, including compliance with Australian laws.
6. Department of Justice NSW – Trusts and Trustees
   URL: https://www.justice.nsw.gov.au/trusts-and-trustees
   Offers resources and legal advice for trustees managing estates, including information on their legal duties and how to avoid common pitfalls.
7. Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) – Trusts
   URL: https://asic.gov.au/regulatory-resources/financial-services/guidance/trustees/
   Provides a detailed overview of the regulations governing trustees, including compliance requirements and penalties for breaches.

Non-Profit Organizations

1. The Law Society of New South Wales – Trustee Responsibilities
   URL: https://www.lawsociety.com.au/legal-help/probate-estate-administration/trustee-responsibilities
   Offers legal advice and resources specifically for trustees, including how to navigate complex probate cases.
2. Justice Connect – Trustee Support
   URL: https://justiceconnect.org.au/resources/trustee-support/
   Provides free legal resources and advice for trustees facing legal challenges or disputes with beneficiaries.

Tags and Keywords:

trust and probate, trust in probate, trust versus probate, public trustee probate, probate trust fund, probate trustee, probate & trusts, probate vs trust, testamentary trust probate, do testamentary trusts avoid probate, does a testamentary trust avoid probate, does a testamentary trust go through probate, trust probate attorney, trusts & probate solicitors st neots, trust and probate attorney, trust and probate lawyer, trusts and probate attorney, trusts and probate lawyer, trusts and probate solicitors, trust and probate disputes lawyers, trust and probate administration lawyer, trust avoid probate, trusts and wills avoiding probate, trusts to avoid probate, trusts vs wills avoiding probate, trust & probate, trust & probate disputes, trust & probate litigation, trust account probate, trust and probate insurance, trust and probate law, trust and probate law group, trust and probate litigation, trust and will probate, trust and will probate reviews, trust assets and personal assets probate include, trust assets and probate, trust assets and probate include, trust contentious and probate barristers, trust probate, trust probate loans, trust probate questions, trust sale vs probate sale, trust under will probate, trust vs will probate, trust wills and probate limited, trusts and probate, trusts equity and probate list, trusts probate, trust & estate administration 94598, trust & estate planning administration in nh, trust and estate administration, trust and estate administration services, trust and estate administration services u.s., trust to avoid probate, trust vs probate, trust wills and probate, trust and estate administration software, trusts in wills, trusted wills, do trustees get interest on probate while in there care, do trusts avoid probate, do trusts bypass probate, do trusts go through probate, do trusts have to go through probate, nm trust and probate law firm, are trusts subject to probate, nsw trustee and guardian probate, tax trust and probate, nsw trustee and guardian estate administration, is a trust better than probate, will trust probate, state trustees probate, state trustees wills, pulic truste probate costs nsw, wills trusts and estates administration, wills trusts and probate, wills trusts probate, wills trusts and estate administration, wills trusts, wills trusts and estates, living trust probate lawyers, public trustee nsw probate fees, does a trust have to be probated, living trust avoid probate, does a trust bypass probate, does a trust go through probate, does a trust have to go through probate, family trust assets and probate include, living trust after probate, living trust and probate court, living trust bypass probate, living trust no probate, living trust probate real estate, public trustee grant of probate, public trustee order of probate, public trustee probate nsw, public trustee probate wills online, public trustee estate administration, does a trust avoid probate, living trust to avoid probate, living trust and probate, living trust probate, living trust vs probate, public trustee letter of administration, estate trust administration, public trustee letters of administration, public trustee administration of estate, public trustee wills nsw, public trust wills, public trustee wills, probate trust attorney, probate trust attorney near me, probate trust administration, contest trust and probate, deed of trust probate, probate trust definition, probate trust law, probate trusts, probate trust, estate & trust administration lawyers, property trusts and probate list, estate & trust administration, estate & trust administration for dummies 2nd edition, estate & trust administration law, estate & trust administration support, estate & trust administration for dummies, types of trusts for wills, wills and trustees, probate & trust administration attorney, probate & trust administration lawyers, contested trust and probate dispute solicitors, probate & trust administration, probate & trust administration faq, contested trusts and probate, do living trusts avoid probate, probate & trust, probate & trust litigation, resolving trustee disputes in wills and probate, revocable trust probate, revocable trusts and probate, wills and trusts, nsw public trustees office probate fees, estate and trust administration attorneys, estate and trust administration attorneys near me, estate and trust administration lawyer, estate and trust administration lawyers, estate and trust administration lawyers near me, estate and trust administration lawyer fl, estate and trust administration lawyers near arlington, estate and trust administration lawyers in falls church, estate and trust administration attorneys in falls church, estate and trust administration attorneys near mclean, creating a trust to avoid probate, how does a trust avoid probate, probate or trust, probate or trust loans, probate vs trust vs will, estate and trust administration for dummies 2nd edition, estate and trust administration for dummies 2nd edition pdf, estate and trust administration near me, estate and trust planning administration, estate and trust administration, estate and trust administration for dummies pdf, estate and trust administration software, estate and trust administration for dummies, probate and trust attorney, probate and trust attorneys near me, probate and trust lawyer, probate and trusts attorney, probate and trust litigation attorney, probate and trust administration attorney, probate and trust administration lawyer, cost public trustee probate, probate and trust administration, probate and trust administration reno, assets in a trust avoid probate, contentious trusts & probate, contentious trusts & probate legal advice, contentious trusts and probate, if i have a trust do i need probate, irrevocable trust probate, probate and trust, probate and trust litigation, probate and trust real estate sales, probate and trust real estate services, probate and trusts, probate and trusts law firm, do i need a trust to avoid probate, does living trust avoid probate, testamentary trust probate fees, do revocable trusts avoid probate, testamentary trust avoid probate, testamentary trust bypass probate, testamentary trust probate court, testamentary trust subject to probate, testamentary trust and probate, testamentary trust wills, wills public trustee, can the state trustees be removed from probate matter, do you need a trust to avoid probate, does having a trust avoid probate, does a living trust go through probate, does a living trust avoid probate, cost of public trustee administration estate, does pour over trust avoid probate, does revocable trust avoid probate, family probate trust, probate family trust, probate living trust, probate public trustee, probate versus trust, do irrevocable trusts avoid probate, distribution of trust assets to beneficiaries before probate, estate planning trust and probate law, does a revocable trust avoid probate, does irrevocable trust avoid probate, putting house in trust to avoid probate, anglia probate & trusts, are testamentary trusts subject to probate, property probate trust, revocable living trust and probate, revocable living trust probate, estate planning & trust administration attorney, des moines estate trust administration lawyer, does testamentary trust avoid probate, how does a living trust avoid probate, probate avoidance trust, is a testamentary trust subject to probate, probate vs living trust, administration of trust estate, probate wills and trusts, what is a probate trust, administration of trusts and estates, golden probate and trust settlement lawyer, chesapeake wills & trusts probate attorney, golden probate and trust settlement attorney, specialist probate trust, does property in a trust go through probate, mass real estate in trust to avoid probate, does an irrevocable trust go through probate, does an irrevocable trust have to go through probate, how much for public trustee to apply for probate, does an irrevocable trust avoid probate, arlington estate and trust administration lawyers, discretionary family trust distribution probate, discretionary family trust distribution probate au, probate preservation trust, deceased estates and trust administration, avoid probate with a trust, can probate be avoided with a will, discretionary probate trust, estate settlement and trust administration, supreme court listings trust equity and probate list, falls church estate and trust administration attorneys, falls church estate and trust administration lawyers, falls church estate and trust administration, grant of probate public trustee, administration of wills trusts and estates, do you have to probate a trust, law firm of jeffrey burr trusts wills probate, grant of probate right of trustees, family investment probate trust, transfer of property from trustee to beneficiary without probate, certificate in estate and trust administration, probate preservation plus trust, law firm of jeffrey burr - trusts wills probate, attorneys and lawyers wills trust and probate, can you avoid probate with a trust, stowell estate administration trust, probate fees tax deductible to trust, difference between probate and trust, letters of administration public trustee, advertisement of probate company trustee, family probate preservation plus trust, do you need probate if there is a trust, law of administration of estate and trust, certificate of appointment of estate trustee vs probate, estate settlement and administrative trusts, certified specialist in estate planning trust and probate law, letters of administration serve on public trustee, intention to apply for probate qlf public trustee, originating motion for grant of probate by trustee company, does probate take longer when a testementary trust is involved, drizin law probate estate planning wills and trusts, executor's fee for administration of an estate trust, probate-affidavit of executor-beneficiaries discretionary trust, trust and estate lawyers near me, trust estate lawyer, trust and estate attorney, trust and estates attorney near me, wills trusts and estates lawyer, wills trusts and estates attorney near me, estate trust lawyer, estate trust lawyers near me, estate trust attorney, estate trust attorney near me, estate and trust attorney near me