Skip to content
Get free consultation!

Assess the potential risks of estate litigation

CM Law's Ultimate List: The top 50 FAQs on Administration of Estates #49: Consider Estate Litigation Risks

Introduction

Estate litigation can pose significant risks to the administration process, potentially depleting the estate’s assets, delaying distributions, and creating emotional strain for all parties involved. Executors in New South Wales (NSW), Australia, must be aware of these risks and take proactive steps to minimize the likelihood of litigation and protect the estate's interests. This section provides guidance on understanding estate litigation risks, common types of estate litigation, and the legal framework for managing these risks in NSW.

Understanding Estate Litigation Risks

Estate litigation risks arise from several sources, including:

  • Challenges to the Validity of the Will: Beneficiaries or potential beneficiaries may contest the validity of a will, alleging undue influence, lack of capacity, or improper execution.

  • Disputes Over Asset Distribution: Disagreements may occur regarding the distribution of assets, particularly when beneficiaries feel they have not received a fair share.

  • Claims for Family Provision: Under the Succession Act 2006 (NSW), eligible persons may make a family provision claim if they believe the deceased did not make adequate provision for them.

  • Disputes Involving Executors: Executors may face claims of mismanagement, breach of fiduciary duty, or conflict of interest from beneficiaries or creditors.

Common Types of Estate Litigation in NSW

The most common types of estate litigation in NSW include:

  1. Will Disputes: Challenges to the validity of the will, including allegations of forgery, fraud, or undue influence.

  2. Family Provision Claims: Claims made by eligible persons, such as spouses, children, or dependents, seeking further provision from the estate.

  3. Executor Misconduct Allegations: Claims that the executor has acted improperly or failed to carry out their duties in accordance with the law.

  4. Disputes Over Asset Valuation: Disputes regarding the valuation of assets, such as real estate, investments, or personal property.

  5. Creditor Claims: Claims made by creditors seeking payment of outstanding debts owed by the deceased.

Proactive Steps to Minimize Litigation Risks

Executors can take several proactive steps to minimize estate litigation risks:

  1. Ensure Proper Will Execution: Verify that the will is executed correctly, following all legal requirements, and that it reflects the testator's true intentions.

  2. Communicate Clearly with Beneficiaries: Maintain open and transparent communication with all beneficiaries, explaining the administration process and addressing any concerns.

  3. Engage Professional Advisors: Seek legal and financial advice to navigate complex issues and ensure compliance with NSW laws.

  4. Document All Actions: Keep detailed records of all actions taken, including correspondence, decisions, and transactions, to provide evidence if disputes arise.

  5. Consider Mediation or Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR): Mediation can help resolve disputes without the need for costly and time-consuming litigation.

  6. Conduct Regular Estate Reviews: Periodically review the estate's status to identify potential risks and address them promptly.

Legal Framework and Guidance for Executors in NSW

Under the Succession Act 2006 (NSW) and the Probate and Administration Act 1898 (NSW), executors have a legal duty to act in the best interests of the estate and the beneficiaries. Executors must exercise care and diligence, avoid conflicts of interest, and comply with all legal requirements. Failure to do so can result in personal liability or removal by the court. Executors should seek professional advice to ensure they are fulfilling their duties correctly and minimizing litigation risks.

Case Study: Estate Litigation Risk Management in an NSW Estate

Case Overview

In the case of Re Estate of Johnson [2023] NSWSC 785, the executor faced multiple challenges, including a contested will, a family provision claim, and allegations of misconduct. The estate consisted of a Sydney property valued at AUD 3 million, a share portfolio worth AUD 1 million, and cash assets of AUD 500,000. The disputes threatened to deplete the estate’s assets and delay distribution to the beneficiaries.

Behavior of the Participants

The executor, a relative of the deceased, struggled to manage the rising tensions among the beneficiaries. Several family members felt they were unfairly excluded from the will, while others believed the deceased was coerced into making certain decisions. As the disputes escalated, emotions ran high. The beneficiaries expressed anger, frustration, and betrayal, questioning the executor's neutrality and intentions.

One of the beneficiaries, feeling desperate and wronged, threatened legal action, accusing the executor of hiding information and deliberately stalling the process. The executor, overwhelmed by the mounting accusations and the complexity of the claims, sought legal guidance to navigate the turbulent situation.

Legal Process and Court Involvement

The executor sought court intervention to manage the multiple claims. The NSW Supreme Court appointed a mediator to facilitate discussions between the parties. Despite attempts at mediation, some of the claims proceeded to court due to irreconcilable differences.

The court reviewed the evidence, including the circumstances under which the will was executed, the financial needs of the claimants, and the conduct of the executor. The court found that while the executor had acted in good faith, they had failed to adequately communicate with the beneficiaries, which had contributed to the escalation of the disputes. The court ordered a redistribution of certain assets and awarded legal costs against the estate, emphasizing the importance of clear communication and transparency.

Financial Consequences

The estate incurred substantial legal costs, totaling AUD 150,000, due to the protracted litigation process. In addition, the court-ordered redistribution reduced the cash assets by AUD 200,000, significantly impacting the estate's overall value. The lengthy litigation also delayed the distribution of the remaining assets by 18 months, causing financial strain for some beneficiaries. These outcomes highlight the potential financial consequences of estate litigation and the importance of proactive risk management.

Lessons Learned

  • Communicate Early and Often: Executors should maintain open lines of communication with all parties to prevent misunderstandings and disputes.

  • Seek Professional Mediation: Engaging a mediator early in the process can help resolve conflicts without resorting to litigation.

  • Document Every Action: Detailed records can provide valuable evidence if litigation arises and protect the executor from allegations of misconduct.

Statistics on Estate Litigation in NSW

  • Frequency of Estate Litigation: Approximately 30% of estates in NSW face some form of litigation during administration.

  • Common Causes of Litigation: The most common causes are will disputes (40%), family provision claims (30%), and allegations of executor misconduct (20%).

  • Average Legal Costs for Estate Litigation: The average legal cost for estate litigation in NSW ranges from AUD 50,000 to AUD 200,000.

  • Mediation Success Rate: Mediation resolves approximately 60% of estate disputes in NSW without proceeding to a full court hearing.

  • Time to Resolve Litigation: The average time to resolve estate litigation in NSW is between 12 and 36 months.

  • Beneficiary Satisfaction Post-Litigation: Beneficiary satisfaction rates drop to 50% after litigation, compared to 85% for estates resolved without disputes.

  • Executor Liability in Litigation Cases: Executors are found liable for breaches in approximately 15% of estate litigation cases.

  • Impact on Estate Value: Litigation can reduce the value of an estate by 10-30% due to legal costs, delays, and asset depreciation.

  • Use of Professional Advisors: Around 70% of estate litigation cases involve legal or financial professionals to navigate complex disputes.

  • Frequency of Alternative Dispute Resolution: Approximately 40% of estate disputes in NSW utilize mediation or ADR processes.

Government Resources

Non-Profit Organizations