Skip to content
Get free consultation!

Fulfill any charitable bequests

CM Law's Ultimate List: The top 50 FAQs on Administration of Estates #43: Manage Charitable Bequests

Introduction

Charitable bequests, where an individual leaves part of their estate to a charity or charitable cause, are a common feature in many wills. Executors in New South Wales (NSW), Australia, must ensure that these bequests are honored as specified in the will or as requested by the deceased’s family members. Properly managing charitable bequests helps fulfill the deceased’s wishes and can provide significant benefits to the designated charities. This section provides guidance on the importance of charitable bequests, the steps for fulfilling them, and the relevant legal framework in NSW.

Importance of Honoring Charitable Bequests in Estate Administration

Honoring charitable bequests during estate administration is essential for several reasons:

  • Respecting the Deceased’s Wishes: Executors must ensure that the charitable intentions of the deceased, as outlined in the will, are respected and fulfilled.

  • Maintaining Goodwill: Properly managed bequests help maintain goodwill between the estate, the beneficiaries, and the charitable organizations involved.

  • Legal Compliance: Executors are legally obligated under NSW law to execute the provisions of the will, including any charitable bequests.

  • Promoting Charitable Causes: Honoring charitable bequests helps support charitable causes, providing vital resources to organizations and communities.

Steps for Fulfilling Charitable Bequests in NSW

Executors should follow these steps to ensure that charitable bequests are properly fulfilled:

  1. Identify Charitable Bequests in the Will: Review the will to identify all charitable bequests and their specific terms, including the amount or assets to be donated and the designated charities.

  2. Verify Charities’ Details: Verify the legal status, registration, and contact details of the charities mentioned in the will to ensure they are legitimate entities.

  3. Communicate with Charities: Contact the designated charities to inform them of the bequest and confirm any specific requirements or preferences they may have.

  4. Determine Available Assets: Assess the estate's assets to determine if there are sufficient funds or resources to fulfill the charitable bequests after all debts and expenses have been settled.

  5. Distribute Bequests: Distribute the charitable bequests according to the terms specified in the will. This may involve transferring funds, property, or other assets.

  6. Obtain Receipts and Acknowledgments: Request receipts or acknowledgment letters from the charities to confirm the receipt of the bequest.

  7. Maintain Records: Keep detailed records of all communications, transactions, and documents related to the charitable bequests for future reference and transparency.

The Role of the Executor in Managing Charitable Bequests

The executor’s role in managing charitable bequests involves several key responsibilities:

  • Ensuring Compliance: Executors must ensure that all charitable bequests are fulfilled in accordance with the will's terms and NSW law.

  • Communicating Clearly: Maintain clear communication with charities and beneficiaries to manage expectations and avoid misunderstandings.

  • Documenting Actions: Keep accurate records of all steps taken to fulfill the charitable bequests, including any challenges or delays encountered.

  • Handling Disputes: Resolve any disputes or disagreements regarding charitable bequests, seeking legal advice if necessary.

Legal Framework for Charitable Bequests in NSW

Under the Succession Act 2006 (NSW) and related legislation, executors must fulfill all charitable bequests as specified in the will. Charitable bequests may be subject to conditions, such as the charity's legal status, the intended use of the funds, and compliance with any specific directions from the deceased. Executors must also comply with any relevant tax laws, including obtaining a tax-deductible gift receipt if applicable.

Case Study: Managing Charitable Bequests in an NSW Estate

Case Overview

In the case of Re Estate of Thompson [2023] NSWSC 505, the executor encountered challenges in fulfilling a large charitable bequest due to unclear instructions in the will and disputes among the beneficiaries. The estate included a residential property valued at $4 million, cash assets of $500,000, and various personal belongings totaling $200,000. The deceased had left a bequest of $1 million to a local charity but did not provide specific details on how the funds were to be distributed.

Behavior of the Participants

The executor, a trusted family member, was determined to honor the charitable bequest but faced difficulties due to the vague instructions in the will and resistance from some of the beneficiaries. As they tried to clarify the terms with the designated charity and other beneficiaries, emotions began to run high.

Some beneficiaries felt that the bequest was excessive and argued that the funds could be better used to support the immediate family. They became increasingly anxious and frustrated, feeling that their own financial security was at stake. The situation escalated as family members voiced their desperation, fearing that their inheritance would be significantly reduced by the charitable bequest. The tension and suspicion among the parties made it increasingly difficult for the executor to proceed.

Legal Process and Court Involvement

The executor sought clarification from the NSW Supreme Court on how to interpret the vague instructions in the will regarding the charitable bequest. The court examined the evidence, including the deceased's previous communications with the charity and the beneficiaries, and considered the legal obligations of the executor under NSW law.

The court determined that the charitable bequest should be honored in full, as it reflected the deceased's clearly expressed wishes to support the local charity. The court ordered the executor to distribute the $1 million bequest to the charity as intended but allowed for some flexibility in the distribution method to account for the estate's liquidity.

Financial Consequences

The estate incurred legal costs totaling $80,000 due to the need for court clarification and the resulting delays in administration. Additionally, the executor faced challenges in liquidating certain assets to fulfill the charitable bequest, which led to a further reduction in the estate's overall value by $100,000. However, the court's decision ensured that the deceased's charitable intentions were honored, preserving the integrity of the estate plan and preventing future disputes.

Lessons Learned

  • Clarify Charitable Bequests in Wills: Executors should encourage testators to provide clear and specific instructions regarding charitable bequests to avoid disputes and confusion.

  • Seek Court Clarification if Needed: Executors should seek legal clarification when dealing with ambiguous or disputed bequests.

  • Maintain Open Communication: Clear communication with all parties, including charities and beneficiaries, helps prevent misunderstandings and disputes.

Statistics on Charitable Bequests in NSW

  • Prevalence of Charitable Bequests: Approximately 18% of wills in NSW include one or more charitable bequests.

  • Average Charitable Bequest Size: The average value of charitable bequests in NSW estates ranges from $50,000 to $500,000.

  • Disputes Involving Charitable Bequests: Around 10% of estate disputes in NSW involve disagreements over charitable bequests.

  • Legal Costs for Charitable Disputes: The average legal cost for resolving disputes involving charitable bequests in NSW ranges from $40,000 to $150,000.

  • Executor Challenges: About 7% of probate cases in NSW involve challenges related to fulfilling charitable bequests.

  • Impact on Estate Value: Estates affected by disputes over charitable bequests may see a reduction of 5-10% in their overall value.

  • Complaints to Legal Authorities: The NSW Legal Services Commissioner receives around 30 complaints annually related to charitable bequests in estates.

  • Resolution Time: The average resolution time for disputes over charitable bequests in NSW is between 6 and 12 months.

  • Mediation Success Rate: Mediation resolves approximately 65% of disputes related to charitable bequests in NSW without a full court hearing.

  • Tax Considerations: Approximately 15% of charitable bequests in NSW estates qualify for tax deductions.

Government Resources

Non-Profit Organizations