Skip to content
Get free consultation!

If the deceased owned a business, manage or arrange for its sale or transfer

CM Law's Ultimate List: The top 50 FAQs on Administration of Estates #22: Handle Business Interests

If the deceased owned a business, managing its affairs is a crucial aspect of estate administration in New South Wales, Australia. The executor must navigate complex legal requirements to ensure the business continues to operate smoothly, is soldIf the deceased owned a business, managing its affairs is a crucial aspect of estate administration in New South Wales, Australia. The executor must navigate complex legal requirements to ensure the business continues to operate smoothly, is sold, or is transferred according to the will or applicable state laws. This section provides essential guidance on managing business interests, legal considerations, and practical steps for executors under NSW law.

Importance of Managing Business Interests in Estate Administration

Handling business interests properly is critical to maintaining the value of the deceased’s estate. Failing to act promptly or appropriately can lead to financial losses, disputes among beneficiaries, and potential litigation. Executors must ensure that the business is managed or disposed of in a manner that aligns with the deceased’s wishes and complies with legal obligations.

Types of Business Interests and Legal Considerations

Executors may encounter various types of business interests when administering an estate, including:

  1. Sole Proprietorships: Businesses owned solely by the deceased, which must be sold, transferred, or wound up.

  2. Partnerships: Interests in a business partnership, which may require negotiating with surviving partners and following partnership agreements.

  3. Corporations: Shares owned by the deceased in private or public companies, which may involve transferring shares or managing directorship responsibilities.

  4. Trusts and Other Entities: Interests held in trusts or other business entities that require compliance with trust deeds or entity-specific regulations.

The Role of the Executor in Managing or Transferring Business Interests

The executor’s role in managing or transferring business interests includes:

  • Assessing the Business's Status: Evaluating the financial health, liabilities, and assets of the business.

  • Consulting with Stakeholders: Communicating with business partners, shareholders, employees, and beneficiaries to determine the best course of action.

  • Following Legal Agreements: Adhering to any existing partnership agreements, shareholder agreements, or other contractual obligations.

  • Determining the Appropriate Course of Action: Deciding whether to continue operating the business, sell it, or transfer it to a beneficiary.

  • Ensuring Compliance with Legal Requirements: Filing necessary documentation with regulatory bodies, such as the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), and ensuring all legal requirements are met.

Legal Framework Governing Business Interests in NSW

Under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), the Partnership Act 1892 (NSW), and the Succession Act 2006 (NSW), executors must comply with various legal requirements when managing or transferring business interests. This includes adhering to partnership agreements, shareholder agreements, and company constitutions, as well as fulfilling any obligations under state and federal laws. Executors must seek legal advice if they are unsure about their responsibilities to avoid potential liability.

Case Study: Challenges in Managing Business Interests in an NSW Estate

Case Overview

In the case of Re Estate of Thompson [2021] NSWSC 782, the executor faced significant challenges in managing the deceased's interest in a private company. The estate included a 60% shareholding in a family-owned business valued at $4 million, real estate assets worth $2 million, and various other investments totaling $1.5 million. Due to disputes among shareholders and a lack of clarity in the deceased’s will regarding the management of the business, the executor encountered substantial difficulties.

Behavior of the Participants

The executor, a family member and close confidante of the deceased, initially attempted to manage the business according to the perceived wishes of the deceased. However, as disputes arose among the surviving shareholders, the executor faced mounting pressure. The shareholders, worried about the future of the business and their financial interests, became increasingly desperate. They believed the executor was not acting impartially, leading to a breakdown in trust.

The executor, overwhelmed by the complexities of the business and the disputes among shareholders, became indecisive and delayed making critical decisions. The beneficiaries, frustrated by the lack of progress and transparency, felt compelled to seek legal advice. Their desperation grew as they feared that continued delays would devalue the business and harm their financial future.

Legal Process and Court Involvement

The beneficiaries filed an application with the NSW Supreme Court, seeking to remove the executor on the grounds of mismanagement and failure to act in the best interests of the estate. The court reviewed the evidence, including the executor's handling of the business and their failure to engage effectively with the surviving shareholders.

The court found that the executor had not fulfilled their fiduciary duties and ordered the appointment of an independent administrator with experience in managing complex business interests. The new administrator took steps to negotiate with the surviving shareholders, resolve disputes, and stabilize the business operations, but the delays had already caused significant financial consequences.

Financial Consequences

The estate suffered considerable financial consequences due to the delays and mismanagement of the business interests. The family-owned business's value declined by $500,000 due to uncertainty and internal disputes. The real estate assets were also affected, with a combined depreciation of $200,000 due to the prolonged sale process. Additionally, legal fees associated with the court proceedings and the appointment of the independent administrator totaled $150,000. These losses significantly reduced the estate's overall value, impacting the beneficiaries' expected inheritance.

Lessons Learned

  • Timely Decision-Making is Essential: Executors must act quickly and decisively to manage business interests to prevent financial losses and disputes.

  • Seek Expert Advice: Executors should consult legal and financial professionals when dealing with complex business matters.

  • Maintain Open Communication: Transparent communication with stakeholders, including shareholders and beneficiaries, is crucial to maintaining trust and preventing disputes.

Statistics on Estate Administration and Business Interests in NSW

  • Executor Mismanagement: Approximately 16% of estate disputes in NSW involve allegations of mismanagement of business interests.

  • Business Interest Disputes: Around 22% of estates with business interests face disputes over the management or transfer of those interests.

  • Legal Costs: The average cost of legal proceedings involving business interest disputes in NSW ranges from $90,000 to $400,000.

  • Executor Removal: About 8% of probate cases in NSW result in the removal of an executor due to mismanagement related to business interests.

  • Asset Depreciation: Estates with mismanaged business interests see an average depreciation of 15-25% in the value of those interests.

  • Resolution Time: Business-related disputes in NSW typically take 12 to 24 months to resolve through court proceedings.

  • Impact on Beneficiaries: Beneficiaries involved in disputes over business interests may see a reduction of 20-30% in their expected distributions.

  • Mediation Success: Mediation resolves about 70% of business interest disputes in NSW without the need for a full court hearing.

  • Complaints to Legal Authorities: The NSW Department of Justice receives around 140 complaints annually regarding the management of business interests in estate administration.

  • Professional Administrator Appointment: Approximately 6% of estates in NSW involve the appointment of a professional administrator due to disputes or mismanagement.

Resources

Government Resources

Non-Profit Organizations