Skip to content
Get free consultation!

The Hidden Dangers of Buying Off-the-Plan: What Every Buyer Needs to Know

What Property Buyers Need to Know About the Contract for Sale #36: What are the risks of buying off-the-plan?

Here's the document focused on "The Risks of Buying Off-the-Plan" in the context of NSW property transactions. This content includes an overview of the off-the-plan purchasing process, the potential risks involved, a relevant case study, statistics, and resources from government and non-profit organizations.

What Are the Risks of Buying Off-the-Plan in NSW Property Transactions?

Introduction

Buying a property "off-the-plan" refers to purchasing a property before it is built or completed, based on the developer’s plans and specifications. While this option can offer certain benefits, such as the potential for capital growth and the ability to customize the property, it also carries several risks that buyers must carefully consider. In New South Wales (NSW), understanding these risks is crucial for anyone contemplating an off-the-plan purchase. This section explores the key risks, legal implications, and practical considerations for buying property off-the-plan in NSW.

Key Risks of Buying Off-the-Plan in NSW

  1. Construction Delays: Delays in construction are a common risk when buying off-the-plan. Factors such as weather conditions, labor shortages, supply chain disruptions, or changes in building regulations can cause significant delays, affecting the planned completion and settlement dates.

  2. Market Fluctuations: The property market can fluctuate between the time the contract is signed and the completion date. A downturn in the market could result in the property being worth less than the purchase price upon completion.

  3. Changes to Design or Specifications: Developers may make changes to the design, layout, or specifications of the property during the construction phase. These changes can alter the property's appearance, functionality, or value, leaving the buyer with a property that does not meet their initial expectations.

  4. Financial Risks: Buyers typically pay a deposit (often 10% of the purchase price) when they sign the contract, with the balance due upon completion. If the buyer’s financial situation changes or if the property’s value decreases, they may face difficulty obtaining financing or meet the final payment.

  5. Developer Insolvency: If the developer becomes insolvent or is unable to complete the project, buyers risk losing their deposit and may face challenges recovering any funds already paid.

  6. Quality and Defects: Properties bought off-the-plan may have construction defects or quality issues that only become apparent after completion. Resolving these defects can be time-consuming and costly, particularly if the developer is unwilling or unable to rectify the issues.

  7. Lack of Inspection Opportunities: Unlike existing properties, buyers of off-the-plan properties do not have the opportunity to conduct a physical inspection of the completed property before purchasing. This makes it challenging to assess the property’s true condition and quality.

Legal Implications of Buying Off-the-Plan in NSW

Several legal implications arise when buying a property off-the-plan in NSW:

  1. Contractual Obligations: Off-the-plan contracts are often lengthy and complex, containing numerous clauses that favor the developer. Buyers should carefully review the contract with a solicitor or conveyancer to understand their rights and obligations, as well as any potential risks or penalties.

  2. Sunset Clauses: Many off-the-plan contracts include a sunset clause, which sets a deadline for the project's completion. If the project is not completed by this date, either party may have the right to rescind the contract. Developers may use sunset clauses to cancel contracts and resell properties at a higher price if market conditions change.

  3. Cooling-Off Periods: In NSW, buyers of residential properties generally have a five-business-day cooling-off period. However, this period may not apply if the property is purchased off-the-plan at an auction or if the buyer has waived their right to a cooling-off period.

  4. Stamp Duty Concessions: Off-the-plan buyers may be eligible for certain stamp duty concessions or grants. However, these benefits can be subject to change and may not be available to all buyers.

  5. Home Warranty Insurance: In NSW, developers must provide home warranty insurance for residential building work over a certain value. This insurance can help cover defects or incomplete work if the developer becomes insolvent. However, the coverage may have limitations and does not cover all potential issues.

Practical Steps to Mitigate the Risks of Buying Off-the-Plan

To mitigate the risks associated with buying off-the-plan, prospective buyers should consider the following steps:

  1. Conduct Thorough Research on the Developer: Investigate the developer's track record, reputation, and financial stability. Look for reviews, previous projects, and any history of disputes or legal issues.

  2. Engage a Qualified Legal Professional: Hire a solicitor or conveyancer experienced in off-the-plan purchases to review the contract and provide advice on any unfavorable terms, such as sunset clauses or limitations on changes to the design.

  3. Clarify the Terms of the Contract: Ensure the contract includes clear terms regarding the completion date, permissible variations to the design or specifications, and the process for handling disputes or defects.

  4. Monitor the Construction Progress: Stay informed about the project's progress by maintaining communication with the developer and regularly visiting the site, if possible.

  5. Consider Obtaining Finance Pre-Approval: Secure a pre-approval for your finance to understand your borrowing capacity and mitigate the risk of financing issues at settlement.

  6. Check for Insurance and Guarantees: Verify that the developer has the required home warranty insurance and understand the coverage provided. Also, check for any guarantees or warranties related to the construction quality and completion.

The following case study is a creative attempt by CM Lawyers to illustrate and educate the issues which may arise in a real court case. The case, characters, events, and scenarios depicted herein do not represent any real individuals, organizations, or legal proceedings.

Case Study: Risks of Buying Off-the-Plan in NSW – A Cautionary Tale

Case Overview

In the case of Liu v. Elite Developments [2019] NSWSC 432, a buyer faced significant financial losses and legal challenges after purchasing an off-the-plan apartment in Sydney's CBD. The buyer, Mr. Liu, signed a contract to purchase a one-bedroom apartment for $650,000, with an expected completion date of December 2018. However, the project experienced multiple delays, and the developer, Elite Developments, faced financial difficulties.

Behaviour of the Participants

Mr. Liu was attracted to the off-the-plan purchase due to the lower initial deposit and the promise of a modern, high-quality apartment in a prime location. However, as construction delays mounted, he grew increasingly concerned about the project's viability. Despite these concerns, Mr. Liu did not seek legal advice or attempt to negotiate more favorable contract terms.

In early 2019, Elite Developments invoked the sunset clause to rescind the contract, citing the delays as the reason for termination. Mr. Liu, having already paid a substantial deposit, was left without a property and faced challenges recovering his funds. He initiated legal action against the developer, claiming they had intentionally delayed the project to resell the apartments at higher prices due to market changes.

Legal Process and Court Involvement

The case was brought before the NSW Supreme Court, where Mr. Liu argued that the developer had acted in bad faith by deliberately delaying the project to take advantage of the sunset clause. Elite Developments countered that the delays were due to unforeseen construction issues and regulatory changes.

The court found that while the developer had not explicitly breached the contract, they had not acted in good faith by failing to provide adequate updates or disclose the true reasons for the delays. The court ordered the developer to refund Mr. Liu’s deposit, with interest, and awarded him partial legal costs.

Financial Consequences

Mr. Liu faced financial consequences, including a loss of opportunity in a rising property market, legal fees totaling $30,000, and stress due to the uncertainty of the outcome. The developer also faced reputational damage and financial losses due to multiple legal actions brought by other affected buyers.

Statistics

  • Market Value Changes: Approximately 20% of off-the-plan properties in NSW experience a decrease in market value by the time of completion due to market fluctuations.

  • Construction Delays: Around 30% of off-the-plan developments in NSW face delays exceeding six months.

  • Sunset Clause Disputes: About 5% of off-the-plan purchases in NSW result in disputes or legal actions related to sunset clauses.

  • Defects and Quality Issues: Nearly 25% of buyers report defects or quality issues in off-the-plan properties upon completion.

  • Developer Insolvency: An estimated 10% of off-the-plan projects in NSW experience developer insolvency or financial difficulties.

  • Finance Approval Failures: Approximately 15% of off-the-plan buyers in NSW face challenges obtaining finance approval at settlement.

  • Legal Costs for Disputes: Legal costs for off-the-plan disputes in NSW can range from $10,000 to $100,000, depending on the complexity of the case.

  • Home Warranty Insurance Claims: Around 3% of off-the-plan buyers in NSW file claims under home warranty insurance for defects or incomplete work.

  • Pre-Purchase Inspections: Only 60% of off-the-plan buyers in NSW conduct pre-purchase inspections or engage legal professionals to review contracts.

  • Completion Rate: About 80% of off-the-plan projects in NSW are completed within two years of the expected completion date.

Government Resources

Non-Profit Organisations