Skip to content
Get free consultation!

The Contract Catastrophe: Consequences of Breaching Property Sale Agreements

What Property Buyers Need to Know About the Contract for Sale #40: What are the consequences of breaching the contract?

Introduction

In New South Wales (NSW), breaching a contract in a property transaction can have significant legal and financial consequences for both buyers and sellers. A contract is a legally binding agreement that sets out the terms and conditions of a property sale. When one party fails to fulfill their contractual obligations, they may face various penalties, including financial damages, termination of the contract, and legal action. This section explores the potential consequences of breaching a contract, the legal framework in NSW, and practical steps to address or avoid breaches.

Understanding Contract Breach in NSW Property Transactions

A contract breach occurs when one party fails to perform their obligations under the contract's terms. In property transactions, common breaches include:

  1. Failure to Settle on Time: If the buyer does not provide the full purchase amount by the agreed settlement date, they may breach the contract.

  2. Failure to Vacate the Property: The seller may breach the contract by failing to vacate the property or leave it in the agreed condition by the settlement date.

  3. Non-Disclosure of Material Facts: Sellers are required to disclose known issues that could affect the property's value or use. Failure to do so may constitute a breach of contract.

  4. Misrepresentation: Providing false or misleading information about the property, such as its condition or size, can lead to a breach.

  5. Failure to Obtain Finance: Buyers who do not secure the necessary financing within the timeframes specified in the contract may breach the contract.

  6. Ignoring Special Conditions: If either party fails to meet any special conditions outlined in the contract (such as repairs, pest control, or inspections), they may be in breach.

Legal Consequences of Breaching a Contract in NSW

Breaching a contract in NSW can lead to several legal consequences:

  1. Termination of the Contract: The non-breaching party may have the right to terminate the contract if the breach is considered "repudiatory," meaning it significantly undermines the contract's terms. This can lead to the end of the transaction.

  2. Retention or Forfeiture of Deposit: If the buyer breaches the contract, the seller may retain the buyer's deposit, typically 10% of the purchase price, as compensation for the breach.

  3. Damages: The non-breaching party may seek damages for any financial losses resulting from the breach. This can include legal fees, costs associated with finding a new buyer or seller, and compensation for any financial losses due to market fluctuations.

  4. Specific Performance: The court may order "specific performance," requiring the breaching party to fulfill their contractual obligations. This is often used when financial compensation is inadequate.

  5. Legal Action: The non-breaching party may initiate legal action to recover damages or enforce the contract's terms, leading to additional costs and delays.

  6. Interest and Penalties: The contract may specify interest or penalties for late settlement or other breaches. These penalties can accumulate quickly, increasing the financial burden on the breaching party.

Practical Steps to Address or Avoid Contract Breaches

To avoid or address breaches of contract, parties should consider the following steps:

  1. Understand the Contract Terms: Both parties should thoroughly review the contract with a solicitor or conveyancer to ensure they understand their obligations and the consequences of non-compliance.

  2. Communicate Clearly: Open communication between the buyer, seller, and their representatives can help prevent misunderstandings that might lead to a breach.

  3. Seek Extensions Where Necessary: If it becomes apparent that a party cannot meet their obligations, they should seek an extension from the other party as early as possible. This may involve negotiating new terms or deadlines.

  4. Fulfill All Conditions: Ensure all conditions outlined in the contract, such as obtaining financing, completing inspections, or undertaking repairs, are met within the specified timeframes.

  5. Document All Actions: Keep detailed records of all communications, agreements, and actions taken to demonstrate good faith and compliance with the contract terms.

  6. Seek Legal Advice Promptly: If a breach occurs or is likely to occur, seek legal advice immediately to understand the potential consequences and explore options for resolution.

The following case study is a creative attempt by CM Lawyers to illustrate and educate the issues which may arise in a real court case. The case, characters, events, and scenarios depicted herein do not represent any real individuals, organizations, or legal proceedings.

Case Study: Consequences of Breaching a Contract in NSW – A Costly Dispute

Case Overview

In the case of Nguyen v. Roberts [2021] NSWSC 789, a breach of contract led to significant legal and financial repercussions for both parties. The seller, Mr. Roberts, had agreed to sell a three-bedroom house in Newcastle to Mr. Nguyen for $1.2 million, with a settlement date set for June 30, 2021. However, Mr. Nguyen failed to secure the necessary financing by the settlement date, resulting in a breach of contract.

Behaviour of the Participants

Mr. Nguyen, confident in his ability to obtain financing, did not take sufficient precautions to ensure his loan approval was finalized. When his initial loan application was declined, he scrambled to find alternative funding but failed to meet the settlement deadline. Mr. Roberts, relying on the proceeds from the sale to finance his next property purchase, refused to grant an extension and chose to terminate the contract.

The relationship between the two parties quickly deteriorated, and Mr. Roberts sought to retain Mr. Nguyen’s deposit and recover additional damages. Mr. Nguyen, feeling he had been unfairly treated, decided to challenge the seller’s actions in court, arguing that he should be granted more time due to unforeseen circumstances.

Legal Process and Court Involvement

The case was brought before the NSW Supreme Court, where both parties presented evidence regarding their actions and the circumstances leading to the breach. The court found that Mr. Nguyen had indeed breached the contract by failing to secure finance and settle on time. The court upheld Mr. Roberts's right to retain the $120,000 deposit and awarded him an additional $30,000 in damages to cover legal fees and other expenses incurred due to the breach.

Financial Consequences

The breach of contract had substantial financial consequences for both parties. Mr. Nguyen lost his deposit of $120,000, faced additional legal fees of $15,000, and suffered damage to his credit rating, impacting his ability to secure future loans. Mr. Roberts, while retaining the deposit and receiving compensation, experienced delays and incurred costs associated with relisting the property and finding a new buyer.

Statistics

  • Frequency of Contract Breaches: Approximately 10% of property transactions in NSW involve some form of contract breach, with common breaches including failure to settle on time and non-disclosure of material facts.

  • Retention of Deposit: In around 8% of contract breaches, the seller retains the buyer’s deposit, typically amounting to 5-10% of the purchase price.

  • Legal Costs for Disputes: Legal fees for resolving contract disputes in NSW can range from $10,000 to $100,000, depending on the complexity of the case.

  • Court Orders for Specific Performance: About 5% of property contract breaches in NSW result in court orders for specific performance, requiring the breaching party to fulfill their contractual obligations.

  • Average Time to Resolve Disputes: The average time to resolve contract disputes in NSW courts is 6-12 months.

  • Impact on Property Value: Properties involved in contract breaches can experience a 5-15% reduction in market value due to delays, legal disputes, or market changes.

  • Buyers Facing Finance Issues: Approximately 15% of buyers in NSW face challenges obtaining finance by the settlement date, leading to potential breaches.

  • Use of Solicitors or Conveyancers: Around 90% of buyers and sellers in NSW engage solicitors or conveyancers to handle property transactions and mitigate the risk of breaches.

  • Dispute Resolution Through Negotiation: About 70% of contract breaches in NSW are resolved through negotiation or mediation without resorting to court action.

  • Buyer Awareness: Approximately 80% of buyers in NSW are aware of the potential consequences of breaching a contract.

Government Resources

Non-Profit Organisations