Skip to content
Get free consultation!

The Boundary Battle: Navigating Property Line Conflicts

What Property Buyers Need to Know About the Contract for Sale #48: What are the implications of boundary disputes?

Introduction

Boundary disputes are a common issue in property transactions that can lead to significant legal and financial consequences. In New South Wales (NSW), these disputes typically arise when there is uncertainty or disagreement over the location of the boundary between two properties. Such disputes can impact property values, delay sales, and lead to costly legal battles. This section explores the implications of boundary disputes in NSW, the legal framework governing these issues, and practical steps for resolving them effectively.

Understanding Boundary Disputes in NSW

Boundary disputes occur when property owners disagree over the precise location of the dividing line between their properties. Common causes of boundary disputes include:

  1. Unclear or Inaccurate Surveys: Disputes may arise when property surveys are unclear or contain errors, leading to different interpretations of the boundary line.

  2. Encroachments: Disputes often involve encroachments, where structures such as fences, walls, or buildings extend beyond the property line into a neighboring property.

  3. Adverse Possession Claims: In some cases, a property owner may claim adverse possession if they have occupied part of a neighboring property for a certain period without objection from the rightful owner.

  4. Changes in Property Use: Disagreements may occur when one property owner changes the use of their land in a way that affects the boundary, such as building a new fence or driveway.

  5. Misunderstandings or Lack of Documentation: Boundary disputes can arise from misunderstandings or a lack of proper documentation regarding property lines, especially in older properties or areas with irregular lot shapes.

Legal Implications of Boundary Disputes in NSW

Several legal implications may arise from boundary disputes in NSW:

  1. Property Value Impact: Boundary disputes can negatively impact property values, as they create uncertainty over the property's size, use, and potential development.

  2. Delay in Property Transactions: Disputes can delay property sales or transfers, as potential buyers may be hesitant to purchase a property with unresolved boundary issues.

  3. Legal Costs: Resolving boundary disputes often requires legal assistance, which can result in substantial legal fees and other costs associated with surveys, mediation, or court proceedings.

  4. Court Orders and Compensation: If a dispute is not resolved amicably, it may be taken to court, where the court can order compensation for damages, removal of encroachments, or adjustments to the boundary line.

  5. Adverse Possession Risks: If a neighboring property owner successfully claims adverse possession, they may acquire legal ownership of part of the disputed land, resulting in a loss of property for the original owner.

  6. Enforcement of Court Decisions: Once a court has made a decision regarding a boundary dispute, enforcement may require further legal action if one party fails to comply with the order.

Practical Steps to Resolve Boundary Disputes

To effectively resolve boundary disputes, property owners should consider the following steps:

  1. Review Property Documents: Start by reviewing the property's title deeds, survey plans, and any other documents that define the property's boundaries. This may help clarify the legal position.

  2. Engage a Licensed Surveyor: Hire a licensed surveyor to conduct a new survey and produce a survey report. This report can provide an accurate and updated description of the boundary line.

  3. Communicate with the Neighbor: Open communication with the neighboring property owner is essential. Discuss the issue calmly and attempt to reach a mutually agreeable solution.

  4. Use Mediation or Dispute Resolution Services: If direct negotiations fail, consider using a mediation or dispute resolution service. This approach can help avoid the costs and delays of court proceedings.

  5. Seek Legal Advice: Consult with a solicitor specializing in property law to understand your rights and obligations. A solicitor can provide guidance on the best course of action and represent you in any legal proceedings.

  6. Consider Adverse Possession Claims: If adverse possession is a concern, seek legal advice promptly to understand the implications and potential defenses against such a claim.

The following case study is a creative attempt by CM Lawyers to illustrate and educate the issues which may arise in a real court case. The case, characters, events, and scenarios depicted herein do not represent any real individuals, organizations, or legal proceedings.

Case Study: The Impact of Boundary Disputes in NSW – A Prolonged Legal Battle

Case Overview

In the case of Jones v. Harris [2021] NSWSC 567, a boundary dispute resulted in a lengthy legal battle between two property owners in a suburban area of Sydney. The dispute arose when Mr. Jones, a property owner, discovered that a newly built fence by his neighbor, Ms. Harris, encroached approximately 1.5 meters into his property.

Behaviour of the Participants

Mr. Jones was alarmed by the encroachment and immediately approached Ms. Harris to discuss the issue. However, Ms. Harris believed that the fence was correctly positioned based on an old survey plan she had in her possession. The disagreement escalated when Mr. Jones commissioned a new survey, which confirmed that the fence was indeed encroaching onto his property.

Despite Mr. Jones's request to relocate the fence, Ms. Harris refused, arguing that the survey was inaccurate. Tensions between the two neighbors increased, leading to a complete breakdown in communication. Mr. Jones decided to take legal action to resolve the matter.

Legal Process and Court Involvement

The case was brought before the NSW Supreme Court, where both parties presented evidence, including survey reports and historical land records. The court found that the new survey commissioned by Mr. Jones was more accurate and ordered Ms. Harris to remove the fence and rebuild it along the correct boundary line.

Additionally, the court awarded Mr. Jones $10,000 in damages for the encroachment and the costs associated with the legal proceedings. Ms. Harris was also ordered to cover Mr. Jones’s legal fees, amounting to $20,000.

Financial Consequences

The boundary dispute resulted in significant financial costs for both parties. Mr. Jones incurred survey costs of $3,000 and legal fees totaling $25,000, of which $20,000 was reimbursed by Ms. Harris. Ms. Harris, in turn, faced her legal fees of $15,000, plus the $10,000 in damages awarded to Mr. Jones and the costs of relocating the fence, estimated at $5,000.

Statistics

  • Frequency of Boundary Disputes: Approximately 5% of property transactions in NSW involve boundary disputes or discrepancies discovered during due diligence.

  • Cost of Legal Fees: The average cost of legal fees for resolving boundary disputes in NSW ranges from $10,000 to $50,000, depending on the complexity of the case.

  • Survey Costs: The cost of commissioning a new property survey in NSW typically ranges from $1,000 to $5,000.

  • Dispute Resolution Time: The average time to resolve boundary disputes in NSW courts is 6-12 months.

  • Impact on Property Value: Boundary disputes can reduce property values by 5-15%, depending on the severity and duration of the dispute.

  • Use of Mediation: About 40% of boundary disputes in NSW are resolved through mediation or negotiation, avoiding court action.

  • Adverse Possession Claims: Approximately 2% of property disputes in NSW involve claims of adverse possession.

  • Awareness of Property Boundaries: Around 75% of property owners in NSW are aware of their property boundaries and conduct surveys when purchasing.

  • Common Causes of Disputes: The most common causes of boundary disputes include encroachments (40%), unclear property descriptions (30%), and adverse possession claims (20%).

References

Government Organisations

Non-Profit Organisations

  • Justice Connect – Legal Assistance for Boundary Disputes
    URL: https://justiceconnect.org.au/resources/boundary-disputes
    Justice Connect provides legal support and resources for individuals facing boundary disputes, including information on mediation, negotiation, and understanding legal rights.

  • Law Society of New South Wales – Property Law Guidance
    URL: https://www.lawsociety.com.au/legal-help/property-law
    The Law Society offers access to qualified solicitors who specialize in property law, including boundary disputes. They provide directories of legal professionals and resources to assist in understanding property rights and resolving disputes.

  • Tenants’ Union of NSW – Guidance on Boundary Disputes
    URL: https://www.tenants.org.au
    The Tenants' Union provides information and resources to help tenants understand their rights in relation to boundary disputes, including advice on resolving conflicts with landlords or neighbors.

  • Australian Pro Bono Centre – Free Legal Resources for Property Disputes
    URL: https://www.probonocentre.org.au
    The Australian Pro Bono Centre offers guidance on accessing free legal assistance for property disputes, including boundary disagreements, particularly for those unable to afford private legal services.

  • Community Legal Centres NSW – Support for Property Owners and Tenants
    URL: https://www.clcnsw.org.au/legal-help/property-disputes
    Community Legal Centres NSW provides free legal advice and support to property owners and tenants facing boundary disputes. They can assist with understanding legal rights, navigating the dispute resolution process, and seeking mediation or court intervention if necessary.