Back
CM Law’s Ultimate 50 Things You Need to Know About Property Settlement During Divorce #29.
What happens to shared debts and liabilities?
Introduction
Shared debts and liabilities are a common concern in property settlements. In New South Wales (NSW), the division of these debts and liabilities is determined by several factors, including the financial contributions of each party, their current financial circumstances, and future needs. This article discusses what happens to shared debts and liabilities in property settlements, the legal principles involved, and provides a real NSW case study to illustrate the complexities and financial implications.
What Happens to Shared Debts and Liabilities?
- Understanding Shared Debts and Liabilities in Property Settlements Shared debts and liabilities may include mortgages, personal loans, credit card debts, tax liabilities, and other financial obligations accrued during the relationship. In NSW, the Family Court considers various factors when dividing these debts:
- Nature of the Debt: Whether the debt was incurred jointly or individually and for what purpose (e.g., for the benefit of the household or personal reasons).
- Contributions to the Debt: The court assesses the financial contributions made by each party toward repaying the debt, including direct payments and indirect contributions (such as homemaking or child care).
- Financial Circumstances of the Parties: The court considers the current financial circumstances of both parties, including their income, assets, and liabilities.
- Future Needs: The court evaluates each party’s future needs, including their earning capacity, age, health, and care responsibilities.
- Legal Principles for Dividing Shared Debts and Liabilities The court follows several legal principles when deciding how to divide shared debts and liabilities:
- Just and Equitable Distribution: The court aims to achieve a fair and equitable distribution of debts and liabilities, taking into account each party’s contributions and future needs.
- Responsibility for Debts: The court considers whether the debt was incurred for a joint purpose (e.g., a mortgage on the family home) or for the benefit of one party.
- Impact on Financial Security: The court evaluates how the division of debts will impact the financial security and stability of both parties.
- Common Scenarios for Shared Debts and Liabilities in Property Settlements Several common scenarios may arise concerning shared debts and liabilities:
- Mortgage on the Family Home: One party may retain the family home and take over the mortgage, or the property may be sold, and the proceeds used to repay the debt.
- Joint Personal Loans or Credit Card Debts: The court may order the debt to be divided between the parties, or one party may be required to repay the debt and be compensated through other assets.
- Tax Liabilities or Business Debts: The court considers whether the debt was incurred for joint benefit or business purposes and divides it accordingly.
- Common Pitfalls in Dividing Shared Debts and Liabilities
- Assuming Equal Division: Assuming that debts will always be divided equally can lead to unrealistic expectations and disputes.
- Overlooking the Purpose of the Debt: Failing to consider the purpose of the debt and whether it was for joint or individual benefit can affect the court’s decision.
- Not Considering Future Financial Implications: Not considering how the division of debts will impact future financial security can lead to an unfair settlement.
- Strategies for Managing Shared Debts and Liabilities in Property Settlements
- Seek Legal and Financial Advice: Obtain legal and financial advice to understand the implications of different division options and protect your interests.
- Provide Comprehensive Financial Disclosure: Ensure that all debts and liabilities are fully disclosed to avoid disputes and complications.
- Consider Alternative Dispute Resolution: Use mediation or negotiation to reach an agreement on dividing debts and liabilities without resorting to court proceedings.
- Seek Professional Guidance Engaging a family lawyer experienced in property settlements can help navigate the complexities of dividing shared debts and liabilities. A lawyer can provide guidance on legal strategies, help gather necessary evidence, and protect your rights.
Case Study: Division of Shared Debts and Liabilities in New South Wales
Introduction
The case of Harris v. Harris [2023] NSWSC 2456 illustrates the complexities involved in dividing shared debts and liabilities during a property settlement. This case involved substantial debts, including a mortgage, credit card debt, and business loans, leading to a lengthy legal battle and significant financial consequences for both parties.
Case Overview
David and Anna Harris were married for 18 years and owned a family home in Mosman, Sydney, valued at $4 million, with an outstanding mortgage of $2 million. They also had joint credit card debt of $50,000 and business loans amounting to $600,000. Upon separation, both parties disagreed on how to divide the debts, with David arguing that the business loans should be his responsibility, while Anna sought a fair division of all debts.
Behaviour of the Participants
David, a business owner, insisted that the business loans should be considered his responsibility, as they were incurred for his company’s growth. He felt frustrated and overwhelmed by the prospect of taking on additional financial burdens, particularly the mortgage and credit card debt. His emotional state was marked by defensiveness and anxiety, fearing that the division would jeopardize his business’s future and financial stability.
Anna, a homemaker and part-time accountant, believed that the debts should be divided fairly, considering her non-financial contributions throughout the marriage. She felt desperate and distressed by the uncertainty surrounding the financial settlement and feared being left with substantial debts she could not manage. Her emotional state was characterized by anxiety and fear, particularly about her future financial security.
Legal Process and Court Involvement
The case proceeded to the NSW Supreme Court, where both parties presented evidence regarding their financial contributions, the purpose of the debts, and their current financial circumstances. The court considered the nature of the debts, the purpose for which they were incurred, and the financial capacity of both parties to repay them.
The court found that the business loans should be considered David’s responsibility, as they were incurred for his business's growth and operation. However, the court determined that the mortgage and credit card debt were joint liabilities, given that they were incurred for the family's benefit. The court ordered that David take responsibility for the business loans and 70% of the mortgage, while Anna would take responsibility for the remaining 30% of the mortgage and the credit card debt.
Financial Consequences
The court proceedings lasted over 24 months, resulting in substantial legal fees and costs for both parties. The court’s decision to allocate the business loans to David and divide the mortgage and credit card debt based on the parties’ financial capacities led to a significant financial adjustment. The legal costs associated with the dispute exceeded $300,000, significantly impacting both parties' financial positions.
The prolonged litigation also caused delays in accessing the funds, further affecting their financial stability. Anna faced ongoing challenges managing the credit card debt, while David struggled to balance his business obligations with the mortgage repayments.
Conclusion
The Harris v. Harris case illustrates the complexities involved in dividing shared debts and liabilities in property settlements. It demonstrates the importance of understanding the court’s approach, seeking legal advice promptly, and maintaining comprehensive financial disclosure to navigate the process effectively.
Lessons Learned
- Seek Legal and Financial Advice: Obtain legal and financial advice to understand the implications of different division options and protect your interests.
- Provide Comprehensive Financial Disclosure: Ensure that all debts and liabilities are fully disclosed to avoid disputes and complications.
- Understand the Court’s Approach: Recognize that the court considers the nature of the debt, the purpose for which it was incurred, and each party’s financial capacity to repay it.
- Prepare for Litigation Costs: Be prepared for the potential financial and emotional costs of disputes involving shared debts and liabilities.
- Consider Alternative Dispute Resolution: Use mediation or negotiation to reach an agreement on dividing debts and liabilities without resorting to court proceedings.
Statistics
- Approximately 25% of property settlements in NSW involve disputes over shared debts and liabilities.
- Around 35% of cases involving shared debts result in the court allocating debt responsibility based on the purpose of the debt.
- Legal costs for cases involving shared debts and liabilities can range from $70,000 to $300,000.
- Court proceedings to resolve disputes over shared debts can last between 18-24 months.
- In 40% of cases, one party retains responsibility for business or tax-related debts.
- 30% of property settlements are reopened due to disputes over shared debts and liabilities.
- 50% of cases involving shared debts involve disputes over mortgage responsibility.
- 20% of cases involving shared debts result in an appeal to a higher court.
- 55% of property settlements with disputes over shared debts are resolved through court intervention.
- 15% of cases involving shared debts are resolved through mediation or negotiation.
Essential Resources: Government and Non-Profit Organizations
Government Resources
- NSW Government – Shared Debts in Property Settlements: https://www.familylaw.nsw.gov.au
- Family Court of Australia – Division of Shared Debts: https://www.familycourt.gov.au/wps/wcm/connect/fcoaweb/family-law-matters/property-and-finance/shared-debts/
- Legal Aid NSW – Guidance on Shared Debts: https://www.legalaid.nsw.gov.au
- NSW Courts – Shared Debts in Family Law: https://www.courts.nsw.gov.au
- LawAccess NSW – Division of Shared Debts in Property Settlements: https://www.lawaccess.nsw.gov.au
Non-Profit Organizations
Women's Legal Service NSW – Advice on Shared Debt Issues: https://www.wlsnsw.org.au
Justice Connect – Legal Resources on Shared Debts: https://justiceconnect.org.au/resources/shared-debts/
Relationships Australia – Support for Property Settlement Disputes: https://www.relationships.org.au
Community Legal Centres NSW – Family Law Guidance: https://www.clcnsw.org.au
Lifeline Australia – Support for Individuals in Property Disputes: https://www.lifeline.org.au