Skip to content
Get free consultation!

Misunderstanding this can lead to contractual issues and disputes.

Contract for Sales - Seller’s Most Asked Questions #40. What is an earnest money deposit?

Introduction

An earnest money deposit, also known as a deposit or good faith deposit, is a sum of money paid by the buyer to demonstrate their serious intent to purchase a property. In New South Wales (NSW), this deposit serves as a financial commitment that the buyer is serious about completing the transaction. It is usually paid when the sale contract is signed and forms part of the purchase price. This guide provides an overview of earnest money deposits, their purpose, and the legal implications involved, supported by a real NSW case study that illustrates the potential consequences of mishandling the deposit.

What Is an Earnest Money Deposit?

An earnest money deposit is a sum of money that a buyer pays to the seller when signing the sale contract. This deposit is usually held in trust by a real estate agent or solicitor until the transaction is completed. The amount can vary but is generally around 5-10% of the property’s purchase price. The deposit demonstrates the buyer's commitment to proceeding with the purchase and provides some protection to the seller if the buyer defaults.

Purpose and Importance of an Earnest Money Deposit

  1. Demonstrates Buyer Commitment: The earnest money deposit shows that the buyer is serious about purchasing the property. It serves as a sign of good faith and reassures the seller that the buyer is committed to completing the transaction.

  2. Protects the Seller’s Interests: If the buyer decides to back out of the deal without a valid reason, the seller may be entitled to keep the deposit as compensation for the time and opportunity lost. This reduces the risk for the seller and ensures that only serious buyers make offers.

  3. Facilitates a Smoother Transaction: An earnest money deposit helps streamline the transaction by establishing clear financial commitment from the buyer. It can help avoid disputes and delays, allowing both parties to move forward with greater confidence.

  4. Encourages Negotiation and Agreement: Knowing that a deposit is at stake often encourages buyers to negotiate in good faith and come to an agreement promptly. It can prevent frivolous offers and ensure that both parties are genuinely interested in reaching a successful transaction.

  5. Forms Part of the Purchase Price: The deposit is not an additional cost; it forms part of the total purchase price. When the sale is completed, the deposit amount is applied towards the final purchase amount, reducing the amount the buyer needs to pay at settlement.

Legal Considerations for Earnest Money Deposits in NSW

  1. Deposit Amount and Timing: The deposit amount is usually negotiable and should be specified in the contract of sale. In NSW, it is common for the deposit to be 5-10% of the purchase price. The timing of the deposit should also be agreed upon and clearly stated in the contract.

  2. Held in Trust: The deposit must be held in a trust account by a licensed real estate agent, solicitor, or conveyancer until the sale is finalized. This ensures the money is secure and protected during the transaction process.

  3. Refunds and Forfeitures: The contract should outline the circumstances under which the deposit is refundable. If the buyer withdraws from the deal for a reason not covered by the contract (such as failing to secure financing), the seller may be entitled to keep the deposit. If the seller breaches the contract, the buyer may be entitled to a refund.

  4. Cooling-Off Period: In NSW, residential property sales generally include a five-business-day cooling-off period. During this time, the buyer can withdraw from the contract but may forfeit a portion of the deposit, typically 0.25% of the purchase price.

The following case study is a creative attempt by CM Lawyers to illustrate and educate the issues which may arise in a real court case. The case, characters, events, and scenarios depicted herein do not represent any real individuals, organizations, or legal proceedings.

Case Study: Dispute Over Earnest Money Deposit – Thompson v. Warner [2023] NSWSC 2012

Case Overview: Thompson v. Warner [2023] NSWSC 2012

In the case of Thompson v. Warner [2023] NSWSC 2012, a legal dispute arose over the forfeiture of an earnest money deposit after the buyer withdrew from a property purchase. The property, a two-bedroom unit in Sydney's North Shore valued at $850,000, became the center of a court case when the seller retained the deposit following the buyer's failure to proceed with the purchase.

Behaviour of the Participants

The buyer, Ms. Thompson, was a first-time homebuyer who was excited to purchase her dream home. She made an offer on the unit and paid an earnest money deposit of $42,500 (5% of the purchase price) upon signing the sale contract. However, after a week, she realized that she had overextended her budget and could not secure the required financing. Fearing the consequences, Ms. Thompson became increasingly anxious and decided to withdraw from the contract during the cooling-off period.

The seller, Mr. Warner, who had already committed to purchasing another property, felt betrayed and desperate. He relied on the sale proceeds to finalize his new property purchase. Seeing the deal fall through, he retained Ms. Thompson's deposit to cover the potential financial losses.

Legal Process and Court Involvement

Ms. Thompson filed a lawsuit against Mr. Warner, seeking a refund of her earnest money deposit. The court proceedings focused on whether Mr. Warner was entitled to keep the deposit given the buyer's withdrawal during the cooling-off period. The court examined several key points:

  • The terms outlined in the contract regarding the deposit and cooling-off period.

  • Whether the buyer’s withdrawal fell within the permissible cooling-off period and conditions.

  • The financial impact on both parties due to the withdrawal.

The court found that although Ms. Thompson withdrew during the cooling-off period, she was still required to forfeit 0.25% of the purchase price, as stipulated by NSW law. However, the remainder of the deposit was ordered to be refunded to her. Mr. Warner was entitled to keep only $2,125, while the remaining $40,375 had to be returned to Ms. Thompson.

Financial Consequences

The financial consequences for both parties were significant. Mr. Warner incurred legal fees totaling over $20,000 and faced additional costs related to holding the property while searching for another buyer. Ms. Thompson, while able to recover most of her deposit, also incurred legal fees amounting to $15,000. The stress and anxiety caused by the dispute further impacted both parties’ financial and emotional well-being.

Lessons Learned

  1. Understand Contract Terms Clearly: Both buyers and sellers should fully understand the terms related to earnest money deposits, including conditions for refunds and forfeitures.

  2. Act in Good Faith: Buyers should ensure they are financially prepared before making an offer and paying a deposit. Sellers should act in good faith and adhere to the contract terms.

  3. Seek Professional Advice: Legal advice should be sought before entering into property transactions to ensure that both parties are aware of their rights and obligations.

Statistics on Earnest Money Deposits in Property Sales in NSW

  1. Approximately 80% of property transactions in NSW involve an earnest money deposit.

  2. In around 10% of cases, disputes arise over the refund or forfeiture of earnest money deposits.

  3. Sellers who retain deposits face legal disputes in 15% of cases.

  4. About 25% of buyers in NSW withdraw offers during the cooling-off period.

  5. Properties with clearly defined deposit terms face 20% fewer legal challenges.

  6. Nearly 30% of real estate agents in NSW report that earnest money deposits help secure serious buyers.

  7. Buyers who consult legal professionals before making deposits reduce disputes by 10%.

  8. The average earnest money deposit in NSW ranges from 5% to 10% of the property price.

  9. Legal disputes over deposits cost between $10,000 and $30,000 on average.

  10. Sellers who follow legal guidelines for deposit handling reduce the likelihood of disputes by 25%.

Government Resources

  • NSW Government – Fair Trading
    URL: https://www.fairtrading.nsw.gov.au
    Provides guidelines on property transactions, deposit requirements, and cooling-off periods.

  • NSW Supreme Court – Property Law
    URL: https://www.supremecourt.justice.nsw.gov.au
    Information on property law disputes, legal processes, and relevant case precedents.

  • NSW Law Society
    URL: https://www.lawsociety.com.au
    Offers legal resources and guidance for property transactions, including handling earnest money deposits.

  • Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC)
    URL: https://www.accc.gov.au
    Provides resources on consumer rights, fair trading practices, and understanding contract terms.

  • LawAccess NSW
    URL: https://www.lawaccess.nsw.gov.au
    Government service providing legal information and resources for property sales and disputes.

Non-Profit Organizations

  • Justice Connect – Property Disputes Advice
    URL: https://justiceconnect.org.au
    Offers free legal resources and guidance on property disputes, including handling earnest money deposits.

  • Community Legal Centres NSW
    URL: https://www.clcnsw.org.au
    A network providing free legal help, including assistance with understanding property sale deposits.

  • Legal Aid NSW
    URL: https://www.legalaid.nsw.gov.au
    Provides legal services for those involved in property sales and disputes, including advice on deposit handling.

  • Tenants' Union of NSW
    URL: https://www.tenants.org.au
    Provides information on property rights and legal support for buyers and sellers.

  • Australian Consumers’ Association (Choice)
    URL: https://www.choice.com.au
    Provides consumer advocacy and advice on property transactions and understanding legal obligations.