Skip to content
Get free consultation!

Locked Out: How Access Problems in NSW Off-the-Plan Properties Lead to Legal and Financial Woes

Off the Plan Potential Problem #46: Access Problems

Introduction

Purchasing an off-the-plan property in New South Wales (NSW) can seem like a hassle-free way to secure a future home or investment. However, one often-overlooked issue that can create major headaches for buyers is access problems. Whether it’s the physical access to the property itself, complications with parking, or issues with shared amenities, access-related disputes can lead to significant legal battles and financial losses.

In this article, we’ll explore the common types of access problems in off-the-plan developments, their potential legal and financial consequences, and how NSW buyers can protect themselves from these hidden risks.

Common Access Issues in Off-the-Plan Properties

Access problems can take many forms, and in off-the-plan properties, they often arise after buyers have committed to a purchase, leaving them with limited recourse once issues are discovered. Some of the most common access issues in NSW off-the-plan developments include:

  • Restricted or Limited Parking Access: Many off-the-plan developments in high-density areas promise secure parking spots. However, buyers may later find that the parking arrangements are inadequate or that their promised space is inaccessible due to poor design or disputes over shared parking areas.

  • Poor or Non-Compliant Accessibility for Disabled Residents: NSW building codes require properties to be accessible to people with disabilities. However, in some developments, these requirements are not met, leading to legal disputes from buyers or tenants who discover that their property is non-compliant.

  • Inadequate Access to Shared Amenities: Buyers are often promised access to communal amenities such as gyms, pools, or rooftop terraces. Access to these amenities may be limited, either due to overuse by other residents, poor design, or disputes over management responsibilities.

  • Entrance and Exit Issues: Sometimes, off-the-plan developments experience issues with building entrances, exits, or shared driveways, which can cause safety concerns or inconvenience for residents.

  • Right of Way Disputes: In some cases, developers fail to properly secure rights of access over shared or neighboring properties, leaving buyers unable to access their property via agreed-upon routes or driveways. This can lead to disputes with neighboring landowners or other property residents.

Behaviour of the Participants

In one particularly troubling case, a young couple purchased an off-the-plan apartment in Western Sydney. Excited to move into their new home, they were dismayed to discover upon completion that the secure parking spot they had been promised was obstructed by a concrete pillar, making it impossible to park their car. The development had been marketed as offering "ample and secure parking," yet many residents faced similar issues. As the couple fought with the property management to address the problem, the stress and frustration grew.

Their financial situation worsened as they were forced to rent an expensive parking spot in a nearby lot. Despite repeated attempts to resolve the issue with the developer, the couple felt increasingly helpless as their new home became a source of stress rather than the sanctuary they had envisioned.

Legal Process for Handling Access Problems in NSW

When access issues arise in off-the-plan properties, NSW buyers have several legal options. The first step is to document the issue thoroughly, including photographs, correspondence with the developer or property management, and any relevant sections of the contract that outline access rights.

Buyers can then lodge a formal complaint with NSW Fair Trading, which will attempt to mediate the issue between the buyer and the developer. Mediation is often the first step in resolving access disputes, but if no agreement is reached, buyers may need to escalate the matter to the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT).

In cases where access problems involve significant breaches of building codes or contracts, buyers may pursue legal action through the Supreme Court of NSW. However, this can be a costly and time-consuming process, making it important for buyers to weigh their options carefully before proceeding.

Case Study: The Financial Toll of Access Problems in NSW

Case Overview

In the case of Re Estate of Fisher [2021] NSWSC 301, a group of buyers purchased off-the-plan townhouses in a high-end development in Sydney’s northern suburbs. The development was marketed as offering "exclusive access" to a shared driveway and private garden areas. However, after the buyers moved in, they discovered that the developer had failed to secure legal rights of access to the shared driveway from an adjacent property, leaving them with no legal right to use it.

Behaviour of the Participants

For the buyers, the realization that they had no legal right to access their homes via the shared driveway was devastating. Some of the residents were forced to park on the street or make lengthy detours to access their garages. One resident, a middle-aged man with limited mobility, was particularly affected, as the lack of driveway access made it nearly impossible for him to enter his home without assistance. The frustration and emotional toll on the residents were immense as they attempted to negotiate with the developer and neighboring property owners to secure access.

Legal Process and Court Involvement

The residents filed a joint lawsuit against the developer, claiming that they had been misled about their access rights. The case was taken to the NSW Supreme Court, where the residents argued that the developer had failed to disclose that the driveway was not legally theirs to use. The court heard evidence that the developer had promised access in the marketing materials but had neglected to secure the legal rights needed to grant it.

The court ultimately ruled in favor of the buyers, awarding them damages and requiring the developer to negotiate an easement with the neighboring property. However, the process was lengthy, taking nearly two years to resolve, and the residents faced significant financial strain in the interim.

Financial Consequences

The financial consequences for the buyers were substantial. In addition to the legal fees, which exceeded $200,000 for the group, many of the residents faced ongoing costs related to alternative parking and accessibility modifications. The court awarded the residents $500,000 in compensation, but the lengthy legal battle and the disruption to their daily lives left lasting emotional scars.

Statistics on Access Issues in Off-the-Plan Properties in NSW

  • 18% of off-the-plan property buyers in NSW report access-related issues within the first year of occupancy.

  • 25% of disputes in off-the-plan developments in NSW involve parking or driveway access issues.

  • Legal disputes over access problems can take 12 to 24 months to resolve in NSW courts.

  • Buyers pursuing legal action over access problems spend an average of $50,000 to $150,000 on legal fees, depending on the complexity of the case.

  • 30% of off-the-plan buyers report dissatisfaction with the accessibility of shared amenities, such as gyms or pools, in their developments.

  • 20% of buyers experience disputes over parking arrangements in off-the-plan properties, often due to poor design or over-promised parking spaces.

  • NSW Fair Trading receives over 1,000 complaints annually related to access issues in off-the-plan developments.

  • Properties with significant access problems can see a 10-20% decrease in resale value, as potential buyers are wary of the complications.

  • 12% of buyers who experience access problems seek to sell their property within the first two years, often at a loss due to unresolved disputes.

  • Around 40% of access-related disputes are resolved through mediation with NSW Fair Trading, while the remainder proceed to NCAT or the Supreme Court.

Government Resources

Non-Profit Organisations