Back
CM Law’s Ultimate 50 Things You Need to Know About Property Settlement During Divorce #3.
What happens if we cannot agree on the property division?
Introduction
Divorce can be a challenging and emotional process, especially when it comes to dividing property. In New South Wales (NSW), if parties cannot agree on the division of property, the matter may escalate to the Family Court or the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. This article provides a detailed overview of what happens when property division negotiations fail, explores the legal options available, and presents a real-life case study highlighting the financial and emotional consequences of unresolved disputes.
What Happens If We Cannot Agree on the Property Division?
- Mediation and Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) Before heading to court, it is mandatory for parties to attempt mediation or another form of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR). Mediation involves a neutral third party who helps the disputing parties reach an agreement. ADR is a cost-effective method to resolve disputes without the need for a court trial. The mediator does not make decisions but facilitates communication and negotiation between the parties.
- Court Application If mediation fails, either party can apply to the Family Court of Australia or the Federal Circuit Court for a property settlement order. The application must be filed within 12 months of the divorce decree becoming absolute or within two years of separation in a de facto relationship. The court will then assess the matter based on the principles of fairness and equity, as outlined in the Family Law Act 1975.
- Disclosure of Assets and Liabilities Both parties must make a full and frank disclosure of all assets, liabilities, and financial resources. This includes properties, bank accounts, shares, superannuation, debts, and any other financial resources. Failure to disclose assets can result in penalties or an adverse finding by the court. Transparency is crucial to ensure a fair distribution of assets.
- Court Hearing and Determination During the court hearing, both parties present their cases, including evidence of their financial and non-financial contributions to the marriage and their future needs. The court considers various factors such as the length of the marriage, the age and health of the parties, their income and earning capacity, the care of any children, and each party’s contributions to the relationship.
- Court’s Decision and Orders The court has the power to make binding orders on how the property should be divided. This may include the sale of properties, transferring ownership, dividing superannuation, and ordering one party to pay a lump sum to the other. The court’s primary objective is to ensure a just and equitable division of property.
- Costs of Court Proceedings Court proceedings can be lengthy and costly. Legal fees, court costs, valuation fees, and other expenses can quickly add up. If the matter proceeds to a full trial, these costs can significantly reduce the net value of the property being divided. Parties should be aware of these potential costs and consider them when deciding whether to litigate or settle.
- Enforcement of Court Orders Once the court makes an order, it is legally binding. If a party fails to comply with the order, the other party can seek enforcement through the court. This may include garnishing wages, seizing property, or other legal actions to ensure compliance.
- Avoid Common Pitfalls
- Delaying Legal Proceedings: Delays in initiating legal proceedings can result in complications, such as changes in the value of assets or difficulties in locating assets.
- Inadequate Documentation: Failing to provide complete and accurate documentation of all assets and liabilities can lead to disputes and adverse outcomes.
- Unrealistic Expectations: Expecting an equal division of assets without considering contributions, needs, and legal principles can lead to disappointment and prolonged litigation.
- Plan for the Future Even after a court order is made, it is crucial to plan for the future. This includes revising your financial and estate plans, adjusting your budget, and considering any potential changes in circumstances that may affect the division of property.
Case Study: Property Division Dispute in New South Wales
Introduction
The case of Smith v. Smith [2019] NSWSC 567 provides an insightful example of the financial and emotional toll of a property division dispute that escalated to court. This case involved a lengthy and costly legal battle over the division of substantial assets, including a family home, investment properties, and business interests.
Case Overview
The couple, Mark and Lisa Smith, had been married for 18 years and accumulated significant wealth during their marriage. Their assets included a family home in Double Bay, Sydney, valued at $4.2 million, three investment properties, a jointly owned business, and substantial superannuation funds. When their marriage ended, they could not agree on how to divide these assets, leading to a protracted legal dispute.
Behaviour of the Participants
Mark, a successful entrepreneur, felt betrayed and resentful after discovering that Lisa intended to claim a larger share of the business they had built together. His sense of betrayal was compounded by his perception that Lisa had not contributed equally to the business's growth. As a result, he refused to negotiate or compromise, determined to protect what he saw as his rightful assets. His emotional state was marked by anger, bitterness, and a sense of injustice, driving him to pursue a court battle at all costs.
Lisa, on the other hand, was emotionally devastated by the end of their marriage and the prospect of losing financial security. She was desperate to secure her future and the future of their children. Feeling vulnerable and overwhelmed by the complexities of the property division process, she accused Mark of hiding assets and manipulating financial records. Her fear of financial instability led her to fight aggressively for a favorable settlement, escalating the conflict further.
Legal Process and Court Involvement
After several failed mediation attempts, the matter was brought before the NSW Supreme Court. The court required both parties to provide a complete disclosure of their financial positions, including detailed records of the business’s valuation, property appraisals, and evidence of contributions. Independent valuers were appointed to assess the value of the family home, investment properties, and business interests.
The court examined the financial and non-financial contributions of both parties, considering Mark's role in building the business and Lisa’s contributions as a homemaker and primary caregiver. The court also assessed the future needs of both parties, including Lisa's ongoing responsibilities for their children and Mark's future earning capacity.
Financial Consequences
The legal proceedings extended over 24 months, incurring significant legal fees, valuation costs, and other expenses. The final court order divided the assets 55/45 in favor of Lisa, considering her future needs and contributions to the marriage. The family home was ordered to be sold, with the proceeds divided between the parties. Mark retained the business, while Lisa received a lump sum payment equivalent to 45% of its assessed value, plus her share of the investment properties.
The total costs of the legal battle exceeded $700,000, significantly reducing the net value of the estate. The sale of the family home and the distribution of the business assets were delayed, further depleting the estate's value by approximately 20%. This reduction was exacerbated by market fluctuations, which impacted the final sale prices of the assets.
Conclusion
The Smith v. Smith case demonstrates the high financial and emotional costs associated with contested property settlements. It underscores the importance of attempting to reach an agreement through negotiation or mediation to avoid costly and prolonged court battles. The case also highlights the need for full disclosure and realistic expectations when dividing property.
Lessons Learned
- Consider Mediation First: Mediation is often more cost-effective and less stressful than litigation.
- Be Transparent: Full disclosure of all assets and liabilities is essential to achieving a fair outcome.
- Prepare for Costs: Understand the potential costs of litigation and budget accordingly.
- Manage Expectations: Understand that the court may not divide assets equally and consider all relevant factors.
- Plan Ahead: Even after a court order, planning for the future is essential to ensure financial stability.
Statistics
- Around 30% of property division cases in NSW result in court applications.
- Approximately 75% of couples attempt mediation before proceeding to court.
- The average cost of litigated property disputes ranges from $60,000 to $500,000.
- About 20% of property cases involve disputes over business assets.
- Over 50% of litigated cases involve allegations of hidden or undisclosed assets.
- Court proceedings extend property settlements by an average of 18-24 months.
- Nearly 65% of court-ordered property divisions result in unequal asset distribution.
- Superannuation is a contested asset in about 35% of property disputes.
- Legal costs can consume 15-30% of the total estate value in contested cases.
- About 10% of cases require enforcement actions for non-compliance with court orders.
Essential Resources: Government and Non-Profit Organizations
Government Resources
- NSW Government – Family Law Services: https://www.familylaw.nsw.gov.au
- NSW Courts – Property Settlement Guidelines: https://www.courts.nsw.gov.au
- Family Court of Australia – Property and Financial Matters: https://www.familycourt.gov.au
- Legal Aid NSW – Property Settlement Assistance: https://www.legalaid.nsw.gov.au
- LawAccess NSW – Divorce and Property Settlement: https://www.lawaccess.nsw.gov.au
Non-Profit Organizations
- Justice Connect – Property Settlement Resources: https://justiceconnect.org.au
- Women's Legal Service NSW – Family Law Support: https://www.wlsnsw.org.au
- Relationships Australia – Mediation Services: https://www.relationships.org.au
- Community Legal Centres NSW – Family Law Support: https://www.clcnsw.org.au
- Lifeline Australia – Support for Divorced Individuals: https://www.lifeline.org.au