Back
CM Law's Ultimate List: The top 50 FAQs on Buying a Residential Investment Property #4:
Property Type
Property Type: Selecting a Property That Aligns with Your Investment Strategy
Choosing the right type of property is a critical decision for any investor in New South Wales (NSW), Australia. Your choice will directly impact your rental income, capital growth, maintenance costs, and overall return on investment. Whether you are aiming for high rental yields, long-term capital appreciation, or a balanced approach, understanding the characteristics of different property types can help you align your investment strategy with your financial goals. Here’s how to select the most suitable property type for your investment in NSW.
1. Understanding Different Property Types
There are several types of residential properties available for investment in NSW, each with unique advantages and considerations. The most common options include apartments, houses, townhouses, and dual-occupancy properties. Let’s explore the characteristics of each to help you make an informed decision.
a. Apartments
Overview:
Apartments are typically smaller properties located in high-density areas, often within multi-story buildings. They are popular among investors looking for rental yield rather than capital growth.
Advantages:
- Rental Yield: Apartments generally offer higher rental yields compared to houses, particularly in high-demand urban areas such as Sydney’s CBD, Surry Hills, and Bondi Junction.
- Lower Maintenance Costs: Due to their smaller size and the presence of body corporate arrangements, maintenance costs for apartments are usually lower.
- Location Demand: Apartments in inner-city areas or near public transport hubs often attract steady demand from young professionals, students, and couples.
Considerations:
- Capital Growth: Apartments may not appreciate as much as houses over time, especially in areas with oversupply.
- Strata Fees: Investors must factor in ongoing strata fees, which cover building maintenance and shared facilities.
b. Houses
Overview:
Houses are standalone properties with land, offering more space and privacy. They are ideal for investors looking for long-term capital growth.
Advantages:
- Capital Growth: Houses generally experience higher capital growth than apartments, particularly in suburbs with limited land availability, such as Balmain, Leichhardt, and Mosman.
- Flexibility: Houses provide more flexibility for renovations and extensions, which can add value and attract higher rents.
- Land Value: A significant portion of a house’s value is tied to the land, which tends to appreciate over time.
Considerations:
- Higher Maintenance Costs: Houses require more upkeep, including garden maintenance, repairs, and renovations.
- Lower Rental Yield: Houses often offer lower rental yields compared to apartments, especially in high-value suburbs.
c. Townhouses
Overview:
Townhouses offer a middle ground between houses and apartments. They are typically multi-story, semi-detached properties sharing one or more walls with neighboring properties.
Advantages:
- Balance of Yield and Growth: Townhouses often provide a balance between rental yield and capital growth, particularly in suburban areas close to amenities.
- Lower Strata Fees: Compared to apartments, townhouses usually have lower strata fees while still benefiting from some shared maintenance responsibilities.
Considerations:
- Limited Capital Growth: While townhouses can appreciate in value, they may not offer the same capital growth potential as standalone houses due to their shared land.
- Moderate Demand: Townhouses appeal to a niche market, such as small families or downsizers, which may limit tenant demand in certain areas.
d. Dual-Occupancy Properties
Overview:
Dual-occupancy properties, such as duplexes or granny flats, consist of two separate living spaces on a single title. They are popular among investors seeking high rental returns.
Advantages:
- Maximized Rental Yield: These properties can generate two rental incomes from a single investment, significantly boosting rental yield.
- Diversification: Dual-occupancy properties allow investors to diversify their income streams, reducing risk if one unit remains vacant.
- Flexible Usage: These properties offer flexibility for future use, such as living in one unit while renting out the other or accommodating extended family.
Considerations:
- Higher Upfront Costs: Dual-occupancy properties typically have higher purchase prices and may require council approval for modifications.
- Management Complexity: Managing multiple tenants and maintaining two living spaces can be more complex and time-consuming.
2. Aligning Property Type with Your Investment Strategy
Your choice of property type should align with your investment goals, whether you’re seeking steady rental income, long-term capital appreciation, or a combination of both.
a. High Rental Yield Strategy
If your primary goal is to achieve high rental yield, apartments and dual-occupancy properties are typically the best options. Apartments in central locations or near universities, such as Sydney CBD, Parramatta, or Newcastle, often have high demand, ensuring low vacancy rates and steady rental income. Dual-occupancy properties in suburban areas like Blacktown or Liverpool can also provide robust rental yields by offering two income streams.
b. Long-Term Capital Growth Strategy
For investors focused on long-term capital growth, houses in desirable suburbs with limited land supply and strong infrastructure, such as Sydney's North Shore or Eastern Suburbs, are ideal. These areas are known for their consistent property price appreciation and appeal to families and professionals. Townhouses in growth corridors, such as the Hills District or Inner West, can also offer capital growth potential while balancing yield.
c. Balanced Strategy
If you aim for a balance between rental yield and capital growth, consider townhouses or apartments in growth suburbs that offer both rental demand and appreciation potential. Suburbs undergoing gentrification or those with upcoming infrastructure projects, like Leppington or Edmondson Park, are good candidates.
3. Case Study: The Consequences of Choosing the Wrong Property Type in NSW
Introduction
In the case of Re Estate of Thompson [2019] NSWSC 736, a poor choice of property type led to significant financial losses for the estate. The executor invested in a high-maintenance, low-yield house in an area where demand was primarily for apartments, resulting in prolonged vacancy and a decline in property value.
Case Overview
The executor purchased a large, standalone house in Sydney’s Inner West, believing it would offer substantial capital growth. However, the property was located in an area predominantly sought after for apartments due to its proximity to universities and public transport. The house remained vacant for an extended period, and its value depreciated due to market conditions.
Behaviour of the Participants
The executor, determined to secure a property quickly, failed to thoroughly research the local market dynamics and did not consider the property's suitability for the area's primary tenant demographic. As the vacancy period extended, the executor's frustration grew, leading to rushed decisions and attempts to lower the rent drastically. The beneficiaries, witnessing the estate's value erode due to the executor's hasty and uninformed choice, became increasingly distressed and pressured the executor for action, ultimately leading to a legal dispute.
Legal Process and Court Involvement
The beneficiaries filed a complaint with the NSW Supreme Court, accusing the executor of mismanagement by choosing a property type that did not align with the local market demand. The court found that the executor had neglected to perform due diligence and failed to select a property that met the investment strategy's objectives, breaching their fiduciary duty.
Financial Consequences
The house, initially purchased for $1.2 million, was sold at a loss for $1 million after a prolonged period of vacancy and unsuccessful rental attempts. The estate incurred additional legal costs of $150,000 due to the court proceedings. After covering these expenses, the total reduction in the estate’s value was nearly $400,000, highlighting the importance of selecting the right property type for the investment strategy.
4. Key Statistics on Property Types and Investment in NSW
- Apartment Demand: Approximately 60% of rental demand in Sydney's CBD and inner suburbs is for apartments.
- Rental Yield Variances: Apartments in Sydney CBD offer an average rental yield of 3.5%, while houses in the same area yield around 2.8%.
- Capital Growth Trends: Houses in desirable suburbs like Mosman and Balmain have experienced annual capital growth of 5-6% over the past decade.
- Vacancy Rates: The vacancy rate for apartments in central Sydney is around 1.5%, compared to 3% for houses in outer suburbs.
- Strata Fees: Average strata fees for apartments in Sydney range between $1,000 and $5,000 annually, impacting net rental income.
- Dual-Occupancy Returns: Dual-occupancy properties can generate 10-15% higher rental yields than single-occupancy homes.
- Land Appreciation: Over 70% of a house's capital appreciation is attributed to the underlying land value.
- Townhouse Popularity: Townhouses account for approximately 15% of new residential constructions in Sydney's growth corridors.
- Property Turnover Rates: Houses in high-demand suburbs turn over faster, with average days on market of 30, compared to 60 for apartments.
- Investment Preferences: Nearly 40% of NSW property investors prefer houses for long-term capital growth, while 35% opt for apartments for rental yield.
5. Essential Resources
Government Organizations
- NSW Department of Planning and Environment
URL: https://www.planning.nsw.gov.au/
Description: Information on property types, zoning regulations, and housing development strategies in NSW.
- NSW Fair Trading – Property Investment Advice
URL: https://www.fairtrading.nsw.gov.au/
Description: Provides guidelines on property types and investment strategies for residential properties in NSW.
- NSW Government – Housing Data Hub
URL: https://www.planningportal.nsw.gov.au/housing-data-hub
Description: Offers data on property types, supply, and demand metrics across NSW.
- NSW Revenue Office – Property Taxes
URL: https://www.revenue.nsw.gov.au/
Description: Details on property taxes and charges, which vary depending on the property type.
- NSW Land Registry Services
URL: https://www.nswlrs.com.au/
Description: Access to historical sales data, ownership records, and property type classifications.
Non-Profit Organizations
- Property Investors Council of Australia (PICA)
URL: https://www.pica.asn.au/
Description: Advocacy group offering resources and advice for property investors on choosing property types.
- Housing Industry Association (HIA)
URL: https://hia.com.au/
Description: Provides reports on market trends and insights into different property types.
- Shelter NSW
URL: https://shelternsw.org.au/
Description: Advocacy and resources on housing types and market conditions in NSW.
- Justice Connect – Property Law Resources
URL: https://justiceconnect.org.au/
Description: Legal advice and resources for property investors, including information on property types.
- Tenants’ Union of NSW
URL: https://www.tenants.org.au/
Description: Information on tenant demand and preferences, which can influence property type selection.