Executor Missteps: The Role of an Executor in Probate

< Back

CM Law's Ultimate 50 List - Probate Problem #19: What is an Executor's Role in Probate?

The role of an executor is a significant responsibility that involves administering the deceased’s estate according to their will and ensuring that all legal, financial, and tax obligations are met. This process is commonly referred to as probate, and the executor is the person appointed by the will-maker to oversee it. This article will delve into the key duties of an executor, the legal process involved in probate, and the potential risks and liabilities an executor may face.

The Key Responsibilities of an Executor

Applying for Probate
Before an executor can officially begin managing the deceased's estate, they must apply for a Grant of Probate from the Supreme Court. Probate is the legal process that confirms the validity of the will and grants the executor the authority to act on behalf of the estate. The application for probate involves several steps:

1. Publishing a Notice of Intent: The executor must publish a notice of their intention to apply for probate, typically in a public newspaper or online through the court's probate registry website. This notice serves to inform potential creditors and other interested parties of the impending probate application.
2. Lodging the Application: The executor then lodges the application for probate with the Supreme Court. This application must include the original will, a certified copy of the death certificate, an inventory of the deceased’s assets and liabilities, and an affidavit from the executor affirming their intention to administer the estate.
3. Waiting Period: There is a statutory waiting period of at least 14 days after the notice of intent is published before probate can be granted. During this time, any objections to the will or the appointment of the executor can be raised.
4. Grant of Probate: Once the application is approved, the court issues the Grant of Probate, officially authorizing the executor to begin administering the estate. Without this grant, the executor has no legal authority to manage the deceased’s assets, which remain frozen.

Preserving and Managing Estate Assets
One of the executor's primary responsibilities is to safeguard and manage the deceased’s assets until they can be distributed to the beneficiaries. This duty includes a variety of tasks, such as:

1. Securing Physical Assets: The executor must take immediate steps to secure any physical assets owned by the deceased, such as real estate, vehicles, jewelry, and other valuable personal property. This may involve changing locks, securing property deeds, and arranging for insurance coverage to protect against loss or damage.
2. Maintaining Real Estate: If the deceased owned real estate, the executor is responsible for maintaining the property until it is sold or transferred to the beneficiaries. This may include paying for repairs, utilities, and property taxes, as well as ensuring that the property is adequately insured against fire, theft, and other risks.
3. Managing Financial Assets: The executor must also manage the deceased’s financial assets, such as bank accounts, investment portfolios, and shares. This may involve transferring funds to secure accounts, managing ongoing investments, and ensuring that any interest or dividends continue to accrue for the benefit of the estate.
4. Valuing the Estate: The executor is required to obtain valuations for all significant assets, including real estate, shares, and personal property. These valuations are necessary for calculating the total value of the estate, which is critical for determining tax liabilities and ensuring an accurate distribution of assets.
5. Handling Digital Assets: In today’s digital age, executors may also need to manage digital assets, such as online bank accounts, social media profiles, and cryptocurrency holdings. Executors must locate and secure these digital assets, ensure they are properly managed, and comply with any legal requirements for their transfer or closure.

Paying Debts and Taxes
Before any assets can be distributed to beneficiaries, the executor must ensure that all outstanding debts and taxes owed by the deceased are paid in full. This is a critical responsibility that involves several key tasks:

1. Identifying Creditors: The executor must identify all creditors of the estate, which may include banks, mortgage lenders, utility companies, and other businesses. This often involves reviewing the deceased’s financial records, contacting creditors directly, and responding to any claims made against the estate.
2. Paying Funeral and Administration Expenses: The first priority for payment from the estate is typically the funeral expenses, which must be reasonable and in line with the deceased’s wishes. The executor is also responsible for covering any costs associated with administering the estate, such as legal fees, probate application fees, and costs for professional services like accountants or valuers.
3. Settling Outstanding Debts: After funeral and administration expenses are paid, the executor must settle all other outstanding debts of the deceased. This may include mortgage payments, credit card balances, personal loans, and any other financial obligations. The executor must ensure that these debts are paid in the correct order of priority, as stipulated by law.
4. Filing Tax Returns: The executor is responsible for filing the deceased’s final income tax return for the period up to the date of death. Additionally, the executor may need to file an estate tax return if the estate earns income during the administration process. Executors should seek professional tax advice to ensure compliance with all tax obligations and to avoid personal liability.
5. Paying Estate Taxes: Depending on the value of the estate, the executor may be required to pay estate taxes. In Australia, this could include capital gains tax on the sale of assets or any outstanding income tax liabilities. The executor must calculate these taxes accurately, pay them from the estate, and obtain a tax clearance from the Australian Taxation Office before distributing the remaining assets.

Distributing the Estate
Once all debts and taxes have been settled, the executor’s next responsibility is to distribute the remaining assets to the beneficiaries as outlined in the will. This process involves:

1. Preparing a Distribution Plan: The executor must prepare a detailed plan for distributing the estate’s assets, ensuring that each beneficiary receives their rightful share as specified in the will. This plan should take into account any specific bequests, such as gifts of money, property, or personal items, as well as any residual assets that are to be divided among the beneficiaries.
2. Transferring Real Estate and Property: If the will specifies that real estate or other significant assets are to be transferred directly to a beneficiary, the executor is responsible for overseeing this process. This may involve preparing legal documents, obtaining necessary approvals, and ensuring that the transfer is completed in accordance with the law.
3. Selling Assets: In some cases, the executor may need to sell assets to generate the funds required for distribution. This could include selling real estate, shares, or other valuable items. The executor must ensure that these sales are conducted fairly and that the estate receives a fair market value for any assets sold.
4. Distributing Cash and Personal Items: Once the estate’s liabilities have been settled and any necessary sales completed, the executor can distribute the remaining cash and personal items to the beneficiaries. This distribution must be conducted in accordance with the terms of the will, and the executor must provide a detailed accounting of all transactions to the beneficiaries.
5. Providing Final Accounts: After the distribution of assets, the executor must prepare and provide a final set of accounts to the beneficiaries. This document should detail all the financial transactions carried out during the administration of the estate, including payments made, assets sold, and the final distribution of funds. Beneficiaries have the right to request a review of these accounts and may raise any concerns with the executor or the court.
6. Handling Disputes: If there are any disputes among beneficiaries or challenges to the will, the executor may be required to resolve these issues before completing the distribution. This could involve mediation, legal proceedings, or negotiating settlements. The executor must handle these disputes impartially and in accordance with the law, ensuring that the estate is administered fairly and justly.

The following case study is a creative attempt by CM Lawyers to illustrate and educate the issues which may arise in a real court case. The case, characters, events, and scenarios depicted herein do not represent any real individuals, organizations, or legal proceedings.

Case Study: Costly Consequences of Executor Mismanagement in NSW

Introduction
In the case of Re Estate of Laughton [2020] NSWSC 1472, the removal of an executor due to mismanagement led to significant financial losses for the estate. This case highlights the importance of selecting a competent executor and the potential consequences of failing to fulfill the role properly.

Case Overview
The executor in this case, a close family member, was initially entrusted with managing the estate, which included several properties and substantial financial assets. However, the executor delayed the sale of key assets and failed to pay outstanding debts, resulting in penalties and a significant reduction in the estate's value.

Legal Process and Court Involvement
The beneficiaries, frustrated by the executor's inaction, filed a complaint with the NSW Supreme Court. The court found that the executor had breached their fiduciary duties and ordered their removal. The legal proceedings lasted over 18 months, during which time the estate's value continued to decrease.

Financial Consequences
The total cost of the legal battle, including court fees and the appointment of a new executor, exceeded $500,000. This amount was deducted from the estate, significantly reducing the inheritance available to the beneficiaries.

Conclusion
The Laughton case underscores the importance of prompt action and careful management of estate assets by the executor. It also highlights the potential financial and emotional costs associated with executor mismanagement.

Statistics

• Executor Mismanagement: Approximately 10% of estate disputes in NSW involve allegations of executor misconduct or mismanagement, with the majority leading to legal action.
• Removal Cases: Around 5-7% of probate cases in NSW result in the removal of an executor due to misconduct, delay, or conflict of interest.
• Legal Costs: The legal costs associated with removing an executor in NSW can range from $50,000 to over $500,000, depending on the complexity of the estate.
• Time Delays: Removing an executor can extend the administration of an estate by 12-24 months, with complex cases taking even longer.
• Financial Impact: On average, estates subject to disputes over executor removal see a 15-25% reduction in value due to legal fees and delays in asset management.

References

• NSW Government – Wills, Probate, and Inheritance. URL: https://www.nsw.gov.au/law-and-justice/wills-probate-and-inheritance
• NSW Supreme Court – Probate. URL: https://www.supremecourt.justice.nsw.gov.au/Pages/sco2_probate/probate.aspx
• Justice Connect – Legal Help for Beneficiaries. URL: https://justiceconnect.org.au/resources/removing-an-executor/

Tags and Keywords:

probate executor duties, executor not applying for probate, executor dies after probate granted, executor dies before probate, executor and probate, executor delaying probate, executor grant of probate, executor loses capacity after probate, executor renouncing probate, can executor act before probate, can executor distribute assets before probate, can executor pay bills before probate, can executor pay funeral expenses before probate, can executor sell property before probate, can executor sell shares before probate, can an executor distribute assets before probate, can an executor pay bills before probate, can an executor renounce after grant of probate, can an executor rent a property before probate is granted, can an executor resign after probate, can an executor sell assets before probate, can an executor sell car before probate, can an executor sell property before probate, do all executors have to apply for probate, do all executors have to sign probate forms, do all executors need to apply for probate, can one executor apply for probate, can one executor apply for probate without the other, do both executors have to apply for probate, do both executors need to apply for probate, does an executor have to apply for probate, does an executor need to apply for probate, probate executor, probate executor of estate, probate executor responsibilities, death of executor after probate granted, death of executor before probate, do joint executors both have to apply for probate, probate vs executor, what if the executor does not probate the will, probate and executor, probate and executors, removing an executor after probate, what can an executor do before probate is granted, what does an executor do after probate is granted, can only one executor apply for probate, why would an executor delay probate, what happens if executor dies before probate, how long can an executor delay applying for probate, grant of probate executor, how long does an executor have to apply for probate, what happens if an executor does not apply for probate, what happens when an executor dies after probate, probate affidavit of executor, duties of administrator of estate, duties of administrator of deceased estate, duties of an administrator of an estate, duties of the administrator of an estate, duties of estate administrator, duties of an estate administrator, duties of executors of wills, director duties during probate, probate and duties of executor, what are the duties of an administrator of an estate, administrator's duties estate, administrator's duties estate nsw, outstanding probate duties, administrator estate duties, estate administrator duties, estate administrator duties explained, can probate be avoided with a will, probate administrator duties, probate administration duties, administrator of estate duties, letters of administration duties, administrator of an estate duties, probate court investigator duties, is probate the same as death duties, administrator of estate vs executor, administrator of estate, administrator of estate fees, administrator of estate meaning, administrator of estate no will, administrator of estate responsibilities, administrator of estate form, administrator of estate without will, administrator of estate definition, as administrator of estate, co administrator of estate, as administrator of estate australia, can administrator of estate sell property, can administrator of estate evict tenants, does administrator of estate get paid, legal administrator of estate, can an administrator of estate get car insurance in probate, female administrator of estate, who is administrator of estate, role of administrator of estate, contest administrator of estate, duty of administrator of estate, special administrator of estate, what is administrator of estate, executor administrator of estate, bond for administrator of estate, death of administrator of estate, power of administrator of estate, file for administrator of estate, apply for administrator of estate, powers of administrator of estate, what does administrator of estate mean, appointed administrator of estate, executive administrator of estate, voluntary administrator of estate, appointing administrator of estate, removal of administrator of estate, what is an administrator of estate, who can be administrator of estate, filing for administrator of estate, payment to administrator of estate, executor vs administrator of estate, executor or administrator of estate, executor v. administrator of estate, apply to be administrator of estate, independent administrator of estate, executor and administrator of estate, appointing an administrator of estate, how much does administrator of estate get paid, appointment of administrator of estate, applying to be administrator of estate, how to appoint administrator of estate, how to sign as administrator of estate, what happens if administrator of estate dies, application for administrator of estate, court appointed administrator of estate, how to file for administrator of estate, who appoints an administrator of estate, how to resign as administrator of estate, abbreviation for administrator of estate, how to apply for administrator of estate, how to apply to be administrator of estate, petition to remove administrator of estate, how to be appointed administrator of estate, responsibilities of administrator of estate, how to apply to be an administrator of estate, difference between executor and administrator of estate, special circumstances are shown to exist administrator of estate, what is the difference between executor and administrator of estate, role of estate administrator, role of an estate agent administrator, role of the executor in a probate case, lawyer's role and actions in estate administration, what is the role of an administrator of an estate, example of cover letter for administration role, administrator or executor of estate, administrator vs executor of estate, administrator vs executor estate, administrator of probate, administrator probate, administrators and probate act s 64, administrator letter of recommendation, administrator of the estate, administrator for deceased estate, administrator intestate estate, administrator of an estate without will, administrator of deceased estate, administrator of intestate estate, administrator of the estate meaning, administrator of the estate responsibilities, administrator wills and estates, administrator fees estate, administrator of an estate, administrator of an estate meaning, administrator of the estate of the deceased, administrator deceased estate, administrator estate, administrator estate distribution, administrator estate meaning, administrator fee estate, administrator for estate, administrator fraud deceased estate, administrator of an estate authority, administrator of an estate power, administrator of an estate pwoer, administrator of the estate definition, administrator of the estate of deceased, administrator over estate, administrator to an estate, administrators of estate, administrators of estates, co administrators of an estate, do administrators of estates get paid, can administrator pay legal fees from estate, the administrator of the estate 意味, joint administrator in letters of administration, joint administrators of an estate, is an administrator of an estate a fiduciary, estate administrator vs executor, estate administrator bond, public administrator probate, can an administrator of an estate be a beneficiary, can an administrator of an estate sell property, can an administrator of an estate take everything, estate administrator, estate administrator fees, can an administrator of an estate be removed, can an administrator of an estate charge a fee, can an administrator withdraw money from an estate account, estate administrator meaning, is the administrator of an estate responsible for debt, can an administrator of an estate file a claim, can an administrator of an intestate estate be challenged, estate administrator cover letter, estate administrator responsibilities, estate administrator search, estate administrator sells property, estate administrator+, estate administrators, is the administrator of an estate get more money, probate administrator fees, special administrator probate, probate administrator, probate administrators, does an administrator of an estate get paid, can the administrator of an estate grant power of attorney, can the administrator of an estate sell property, does an administrator of an estate pay off debts, estates administrator, estates administrator bidwells, does the administrator of an estate get paid, how many administrators can be on an estate, does the administrator of an estate own the property, renounce administrator of an estate, letter of administrator, how is an administrator of an estate appointed, who is an administrator of an estate, do estate administrators get paid, remove an administrator of an estate nsw, temporary administrator of an estate, what does administrator of an estate mean, what is an administrator of an estate, who can be administrator of an estate, can estate administrators take everything, who is the administrator of an estate, what is an administrator for deceased estate, who can be administrator of an estate in nsw, who is the administrator of an intestate estate, executor vs administrator probate, executor or administrator of the estate, executor vs administrator of an estate, removing an administrator of an estate, what can an administrator of an estate do, what is the administrator of an estate, estate plan administrator, withdrawing administrator of an estate, powers of an administrator of an estate, what does an administrator of an estate do, what does an administrator of an estate have to do, applying for administrator to the estate, what can the administrator of an estate do, alure estate administrators, powers of an administrator of an estate jewellery, rights of an administrator of an estate, changing mind administrator letters of admin, changing mind administrator letters of administration nsw, what does the administrator of an estate do, can i sue the administrator of an estate, can i sue the administrator of an estate misleading conduct, marcos estate administrator, who can be an administrator of an estate, who can be an administrator of an estate in nsw, apply to be an administrator of an estate, does an estate administrator get paid, who can be the administrator of an estate, +real +estate +administrators, how to contact administrator of a deceased estate, deceased estate administrator, court appointed administrator of an estate, deceased estate administrator vacancies, deceased estate administrator assistant, ct probate court administrator, how long does an administrator have to settle an estate, can there be two administrators of an estate, how much does an administrator of an estate get paid, can guardian and administrator make claim on estate, cardinham estate administrator, deceased estates administrator, how to change an administrator of an estate nsw, what is a public administrator of an estate, who can apply as administrator of an estate nsw, who is appointed administrator of an estate, cover letter site administrator of material and logistics, how to appoint an administrator for estate, how much does the administrator of an estate get paid, applying to be an administrator of an estate, asset disposal by administrator of represented person estate beneficiary, is an independent administrator of an estate also the solicitor, what is a special administrator of an estate, what is an estate administrator, estate executor vs administrator, difference between administrator and executor of estate, difference between administrator and executor of an estate, surety bond estate administrator, what power does an administrator of an estate have, how do i remove an administrator from an estate, how much do estate administrators get paid, how to apply to be administrator of a deceased estate, independent estate administrator, what happens if the administrator of an estate dies, what does a probate administrator do, who can apply to be administrator of an estate, how to be appointed administrator of an estate, professional estate administrators, what does an estate administrator do, what does an estate administrator get paid, what rights does an administrator of an estate have, who can be appointed administrator of an estate, how do i apply to be administrator of an estate, what rights does the administrator of an estate have, executor of estate vs administrator, how to apply to be an administrator of an estate, who is the executor or administrator of an estate, surety bond for estate administrator, how much can an estate administrator charge, what is an independent administrator of an estate, court appointed estate administrator, how to change existing administrator of an estate nsw, what authority does an administrator of an estate have, whos responsiblevto be administrator of an estate, probate court appointed administrator, how much does a probate administrator make, how much does an estate administrator get paid, what does it mean to be administrator of an estate, how to contest a probate administrator, how do you get appointed administrator of an estate, responsibilities of estate administrator, can there be more than one administrator of an estate, can you have more than one administrator of an estate, what happens when an estate administrator dies, letter of recommendation for administrator, sample nomination letter for administrator of the year, letter of introduction school administrator, what is the fee for an estate administrator, difference between executor and administrator of an estate, letter of authority for network administrator, letter of recommendation for an administrator, letter of recommendation network administrator, letter of appointment for network administrator, sample of cover letter for office administrator, what are the responsibilities of an administrator of an estate, can an executor of an estate fire an administrator, transfer shares from deceased estate administrator and beneficiary same person, identification of the estate executor/administrator, letter of recommendation for database administrator, what percentage of an estate does the administrator get paid, sample of cover letter for accounts receivable administrator, how to transfer shares from deceased estate to administrator, what is the difference between estate executor and administrator, bond application for probate, executor indemnify asset holder to avoid probate, executor has not applied for probate, executor does not move to probate, executor dies after probate, executor dies before probate granted, executor of will dies before probate, executors of wills, executors wills, executor of wills, executor wills, executors for wills, executor of probate, executor of will probate, executor powers before probate, executor probate process, executor account before probate, executor estate probate, executor of will has died before grant of probate, executor probate, executor protection under probate under s 53 succession act, executor refuses to probate will, executor renounce probate, executor renuoncing probate, executor renuoncing probate and family prvsion claim, executor will without probate, executor won t probate will, executors & probate, executors are entitled to apply for probate, executors bank account for probate, executors offering surety with application for probate, executors powers before probate, executor letter of administration, executor letters of administration, executor fees for estate administration, executor & estate administration services, executor's fee for administration of an estate trust, if executor dies before probate, can executor sell assets before probate, can executor sell car before probate, can executor sell house before probate, can executor sell house without probate, can executor of an estate payout before probate, can executor renounce probate, can executor sell house during probate, can executors sell a house before probate, can executors sell assets before probate, can executors sell property before probate, how executor pays for probate australia, two executors each apply for a grant of probate, i am executor and sole beneficiary do i need probate, does executor have to do probate, as an executor do i need probate, joint executor who doesn't apply for probate, joint executors probate, can an executor avoid administrating an estate, can an executor sell a car before probate, can an executor delay probate, can an executor dispose of assets before probate, can an executor pay debts before probate, can an executor sell a house without probate, can an executor sell a property before probate is granted, can an executor sell property without probate, can an executor sell shares before probate, can an executor beneficiary take things from an estatebefore probate, can an executor contest a will after probate, can an executor distribute money before probate, can an executor nominate someone else to apply for probate, can an executor of a will sell items before probate, can an executor pay beneficiaries before probate, can an executor pay out estate before probate, can an executor release funds before probate, can an executor resign before probate, can an executor sell a house before probate, can an executor sell business assets before probate, can an executor sign a contract before probate, can an executor take leave from probate in nsw, how do executors end probate, strata executor probate, can an executor to as deceased estate claim for administrating, probate executor not applying, what an executor cannot do before probate is granted, what an executor cannot do before probate is granted au, what if executor does not apply for probate, if sole executor dies before probate granted, can the executor of a will sell property before probate, can the executor sell a house that is in probate, does an executor need probate, probate executor fees, as sole executor can i distribute funds before probate granted, can two executors apply for probate, do both executors have to sign probate forms, do both executors have to sign probate forms australia, probate executor allowance, probate executor announcements, probate executor lives outside nsw, probate executor power reserved, probate executors, removal executor probate nsw, death of executor after probate, death of executor before probate granted, does the executor have to apply for probate, what can executors do before probate, do joint executors have to go to the probate office, petition executor probate nsw, renounce executor probate nsw, renounce executorship after probate, nominated executor of will dies before probate, wills and executors, wills and executors responsibilities, powers of executor before probate, powers of executor prior to grant of probate, a guide to executorship and probate, appointing executor has responsibility to obtain probate, appointing executor has responsibility to probate, one of two executors applying for probate, probate if executor invests monies, probate if executor invests monies in australia, removal of executor before probate, renouncing executorship in nsw afer probate, renouncing executorship in nsw after probate, how does an executor apply for probate, how long do executors have to apply for probate, removing an executor before probate, what can an executor do before probate, affidavit of executor probate nsw, when does an executor have to apply for probate, affidavit of executor probate, affidavit of executor probate nw, do dual will executors both have to sign probate forms, what does an executor need for probate, probate court executor of estate, what happens if executor dies during probate, court appointed executor probate, what happens if executor refuses to probate will, court appointed executor probate au, probate oath of executor, how long does an executor have to probate a will, how to remove an executor after probate, hsbc probate and executor, probate renounce executor, responsibility of executors of wills, after probate can executor be removed, after probate can executor be removed in australia, responsibility of executors who dispose of assets after probate, what happens if an executor dies after probate, renounce appointed executor probate nsw, grant of probate to executor or lawyer, subsitution of sole executor for probate application, what happens when an executor dies before probate, probate-affidavit of executor-beneficiaries discretionary trust, during probate can en executor sell property, probate returned with executor missing, what happens when a co executor dies after probate, advertisement where an executor has renounced probate, nsw probate affidavit of executor, sample probate letter to executor, grant of probate protects executors by, how to do probate when two executors estranged, calculating commission for executors nsw probate and administration, ts prosperity group probate executor services, letters of administration vs executor, grant of probate protects the executors, grant of probate protects the executors if it gets revoked, original will to be signed by executor for probate, do you need probate to open an executors bank account, grant of probate nsw affidavit executor, how a grant of probate protects executors, how to apply for probate when two executors estranged, is probate necessary if i am both executor and beneficiary, rate of commission on probate for executors, applying for probate if you are an executor, notice intended application probate executor different name than in will, letter of administration substitute executor, letter of administration susbstitute executor, how to petition probate court complaints executor, probate transferring shares into name of executors, supreme court probate query capapcity of executor, supreme court of nsw probate affidavit of executor, letters of administration testamentary or executor, grant of probate power reserved to another executor, difference btween letter of administration and executor, challenging to administration of an estate and removing executors, who needs probate, who has to go through probate, who has to do probate, who has to apply for probate, who does probate when someone dies, who values house contents for probate, who probates a will, who pays probate in australia, who pays probate fees, who pays probate, who pays for probate costs, who pays for probate, who handles probate, who grants probate, who does probate, who can put a caveat on probate, who can probate a will, who can apply for probate, who can apply for grant of probate, who can apply for a grant of probate, who applies for probate, probate shares, paying deceased bills before probate