Challenging the Process: How to Object to a Probate Application
Probate Problem #38: How Do I Object to a Probate Application?
When a loved one passes away, the probate process typically involves the validation of a will and the distribution of assets according to the deceased’s wishes. However, there are instances where someone may feel that the probate application should be contested—whether due to concerns about the will’s validity, the suitability of the executor, or other significant issues. Understanding how to object to a probate application is crucial for those who believe that the process should be halted or reconsidered.
The following case study is a creative attempt by CM Lawyers to illustrate and educate the issues which may arise in a real court case. The case, characters, events, and scenarios depicted herein do not represent any real individuals, organizations, or legal proceedings.
Real NSW Court Case:
Case: *Thompson v Thompson* [2024] NSWSC 1234
What Happened:
In 2023, the death of Peter Thompson, a successful business owner from Sydney, set off a series of events that would tear his family apart. His children were shocked to discover that Peter had left the majority of his estate to his new partner, leaving them with a much smaller inheritance than they expected. Determined to challenge the validity of the will, Peter’s eldest son decided to object to the probate application.
Participant Behavior:
In New South Wales, there are several valid grounds for objecting to a probate application. These include doubts about the validity of the will, concerns about the mental capacity of the deceased at the time the will was made, allegations of undue influence or fraud, and questions about the authenticity of the will.
In Peter’s case, his son believed that his father had been unduly influenced by his new partner when drafting the will, arguing that the significant changes in the distribution of the estate were not in line with Peter’s previous intentions. This formed the basis of the objection to the probate application.
The Legal Process:
To object to a probate application, the objector must file a 'caveat' with the Supreme Court of New South Wales. A caveat is a formal notice that prevents the grant of probate from being issued until the matter is resolved. It effectively halts the probate process, allowing the objector to present their case.
In Peter’s case, his son filed a caveat, citing concerns about undue influence. The caveat was submitted to the Supreme Court, and the probate process was temporarily paused. This gave his legal team time to gather evidence, including testimonies from family members and medical records, to support the claim that Peter was not fully capable of making independent decisions at the time the will was drafted.
Financial Consequences:
Challenging a probate application can be a costly and time-consuming process. Legal fees can quickly add up, and the estate may be depleted as a result of the ongoing litigation. However, if the objection is successful, the objector may be able to recover some of these costs from the estate.
In this case, Peter’s estate was valued at $4 million, and the legal battle over the probate application put a significant strain on both the family and the estate’s resources. The court required the objector to present clear evidence to support the claims, which involved hiring experts and gathering extensive documentation.
Conclusion:
In the case of *Thompson v Thompson* [2024] NSWSC 1234, the Supreme Court of New South Wales ultimately ruled in favor of Peter’s son, finding that there was sufficient evidence to suggest that undue influence had been exerted on Peter when drafting his will. The court ordered the will to be set aside, and the estate was distributed according to the rules of intestacy.
The decision not only changed the distribution of the estate but also set a precedent for future cases involving allegations of undue influence in will-making.
Lessons Learned:
This case highlights the importance of understanding the legal grounds and procedures for objecting to a probate application. It also underscores the need for clear and convincing evidence when challenging a will. For those who believe they have valid reasons to object, it is crucial to seek legal advice early in the process to ensure that their rights are protected.
References:
- *Thompson v Thompson* [2024] NSWSC 1234.
- NSW Supreme Court Probate Registry.
- Legal resources on probate objections and caveats in New South Wales.
Tags and Keywords:
contested wills and probate lawyers, contested wills & probate lawyers, non contentious probate rules, can you contest a will after probate, can a will be contested after probate, can you contest a will after probate australia, can you contest a will after probate is granted, contesting a will after probate, can probate be contested, can you contest probate, contentious probate, contentious probate rules, contest probate, contested probate proceedings, contesting probate, how to challenge probate, how to contest a probate, non contentious probate, uncontested probate, contesting a will after probate nsw, can you challenge probate, can a will be contested after probate is granted, can a will be contested once probate is granted, contest will after probate granted, contesting a will after probate granted, once probate is granted can it be contested, can a will be contested after probate has been granted, can i contest a will after probate has been granted, can you contest a will after probate has been granted, contesting a will after probate has been granted, how long after probate can a will be contested, how long after probate can someone contest a will, how long after probate can you contest a will, how long does uncontested probate take, can you dispute a will after probate, can a probated will be contested, can a will be contested in probate, can someone contest a will after probate, can you challenge a will after probate, can you contest a will before probate, contested wills and probate, contesting a will before probate, contesting probate of a will, do you contest a will before or after probate, does contesting a will delay probate, once a will is probated can it be contested, probate contested will, probate contesting a will, contesting a will after probate nsw, non contentious probate rules 1987, non-contentious probate rules 1987
