Skip to content
Get free consultation!

Accepting too quickly can lead to missed opportunities for better deals.

Contract for Sales - Seller’s Most Asked Questions #22. Should I accept the first offer?

Introduction

When selling a property, the decision to accept the first offer can be both tempting and stressful. Many sellers wonder whether accepting the first offer is a sign of a quick, fair sale or if they could potentially get a better deal by holding out. In New South Wales (NSW), understanding the local market dynamics, legal considerations, and best practices is crucial for making an informed decision. This guide explores the factors to consider before accepting the first offer, supported by a real NSW case study that illustrates the potential risks and rewards.

Factors to Consider Before Accepting the First Offer

  1. Market Conditions: The state of the property market significantly impacts whether accepting the first offer is wise. In a seller's market, where demand exceeds supply, you may receive competitive offers quickly, making the first offer more attractive. Conversely, in a buyer's market, the first offer may be lower, and holding out for a better offer might be beneficial.

  2. Quality of the Offer: Beyond the price, it's essential to assess the quality of the offer. Consider factors such as the buyer's financial position, whether they have pre-approved financing, the size of the deposit, the proposed settlement period, and any special conditions attached to the offer. An offer that appears high but includes multiple contingencies may not be as favorable as a slightly lower but more straightforward offer.

  3. Your Financial Situation: Your financial circumstances play a critical role in this decision. If you need to sell quickly due to financial constraints or to secure another property purchase, accepting the first reasonable offer may be the best course of action. Conversely, if you have the flexibility to wait, you might hold out for a better offer.

  4. Advice from Professionals: Engaging with a qualified real estate agent and legal advisors can provide valuable insights into whether the first offer is fair and how it compares to recent sales of similar properties. Professionals can help you navigate the negotiation process, ensuring that your interests are protected.

  5. Emotional Considerations: Selling a property can be an emotional process, especially if it has been a family home for many years. Weighing emotional attachment against financial pragmatism can help you make a decision that you are comfortable with in the long term.

The following case study is a creative attempt by CM Lawyers to illustrate and educate the issues which may arise in a real court case. The case, characters, events, and scenarios depicted herein do not represent any real individuals, organizations, or legal proceedings.

Case Study: Accepting the First Offer Leads to Regret – Lee v. Harris [2022] NSWSC 1457

Case Overview: Lee v. Harris [2022] NSWSC 1457

In the case of Lee v. Harris [2022] NSWSC 1457, the seller faced significant financial and emotional consequences after accepting the first offer on her property. The property, a two-bedroom apartment in Sydney's Inner West valued at approximately $1.1 million, was sold hastily to the first interested buyer, resulting in a legal dispute over the fairness of the sale.

Behaviour of the Participants

The seller, Ms. Lee, was a single mother under financial pressure due to job loss and mounting debts. Desperate to sell quickly, she instructed her real estate agent to accept the first offer that seemed reasonable, without thoroughly analyzing the market or considering other potential offers. She felt a mix of relief and anxiety, hoping she had made the right decision to secure her financial future.

The buyer, Mr. Harris, was a seasoned property investor who immediately recognized the apartment's potential for growth in value. He sensed the seller's urgency and quickly put forward an offer significantly below the market value, which Ms. Lee accepted without negotiation. As news of the sale spread, Ms. Lee learned that other potential buyers would have offered substantially more, leading her to feel a deep sense of regret and frustration.

Legal Process and Court Involvement

Ms. Lee sought legal action against her real estate agent, claiming negligence and breach of fiduciary duty for failing to advise her adequately and for rushing her into accepting the first offer. The court proceedings focused on whether the agent had provided proper guidance and acted in Ms. Lee's best interests.

The NSW Supreme Court examined several key points:

  • Whether the agent had conducted a thorough market analysis before recommending the first offer.

  • The agent's duty to advise the seller on all available options.

  • Whether Ms. Lee suffered financial loss due to the agent's conduct.

The court found that while the agent had not acted fraudulently, they had failed to provide adequate advice and support, breaching their duty to Ms. Lee. The court ordered the agent to compensate Ms. Lee for the difference between the sale price and a fair market valuation, along with her legal costs.

Financial Consequences

The financial consequences for Ms. Lee were significant. She sold the apartment for $950,000, considerably below the market value of $1.1 million, resulting in a loss of $150,000. Legal costs amounted to over $50,000, and the court awarded her $100,000 in damages, covering part of the financial loss and legal expenses. Major assets affected included Ms. Lee's savings and her ability to secure a new home with sufficient equity.

Lessons Learned

  1. Do Not Rush the Decision: Sellers should take time to consider all offers and seek professional advice before accepting the first offer.

  2. Understand Market Conditions: Engaging with real estate professionals who understand the local market can help in making an informed decision.

  3. Negotiate and Evaluate Offers Carefully: Assess all offers based on their quality, conditions, and the buyer’s ability to proceed without contingencies.

Statistics on Accepting the First Offer in NSW

  1. Approximately 30% of property transactions in NSW involve sellers accepting the first offer.

  2. In around 15% of cases, sellers regret accepting the first offer due to inadequate market analysis or professional advice.

  3. Sellers who wait for subsequent offers receive 5-10% higher prices on average.

  4. About 20% of sellers in NSW accept the first offer due to financial pressure or urgency.

  5. Legal disputes arising from rushed sales account for 10% of property transaction cases in NSW.

  6. Engaging a qualified real estate agent reduces the likelihood of regretting the first offer by 25%.

  7. Around 35% of buyers in NSW make their first offer below the asking price to test the seller's willingness to negotiate.

  8. Properties sold after negotiating multiple offers achieve 7% higher prices on average.

  9. Nearly 40% of real estate agents in NSW advise clients to consider multiple offers before making a decision.

  10. The average legal cost for disputes related to accepting the first offer is estimated between $30,000 and $70,000.

Government Resources

Non-Profit Organizations