Skip to content
Get free consultation!

Obtain appraisals for valuable assets

CM Law's Ultimate List: The top 50 FAQs on Administration of Estates #10: Appraise Assets

Appraising assets is a critical step in administering an estate in New South Wales (NSW), Australia. The executor or administrator is responsible for determining the fair market value of the deceased’s valuable assets, such as real estate, jewelry, artwork, and collectibles. Accurate appraisals are essential for several reasons: they help in calculating the total value of the estate, assist in fair distribution among beneficiaries, ensure compliance with tax obligations, and provide transparency in the probate process. Failure to obtain proper appraisals can lead to disputes, tax penalties, and legal complications.

What Does Appraising Assets Involve?

Appraising assets involves several key steps:

  1. Identifying Valuable Assets: Determine which assets require professional appraisal. This typically includes real estate, high-value personal property (such as jewelry and vehicles), artwork, antiques, and collectibles.

  2. Choosing Qualified Appraisers: Select qualified and experienced appraisers who are experts in the specific type of asset. For example, use a licensed real estate valuer for properties and a certified gemologist for jewelry.

  3. Obtaining Formal Appraisals: Engage the services of these professionals to provide formal, written appraisals that state the fair market value of the assets as of the date of death. Ensure that the appraisals are detailed and comply with legal standards.

  4. Documenting the Appraisal Process: Keep records of all appraisals, including the appraiser's credentials, the methods used, and the final appraised values. This documentation is necessary for probate, tax purposes, and to resolve any disputes among beneficiaries.

  5. Updating Asset Values as Necessary: In cases where the estate administration is delayed or market conditions change significantly, consider obtaining updated appraisals to reflect current market values.

Steps to Obtain Appraisals for Valuable Assets

  1. Identify Assets Requiring Appraisal: Review the inventory of the deceased’s assets and determine which ones require professional appraisal. This typically includes properties, high-value personal effects (such as jewelry and vehicles), antiques, and collectibles.

  2. Select Qualified Appraisers: Choose appraisers with appropriate qualifications and expertise for each type of asset. Ensure that the appraiser is accredited by a recognized professional body, such as the Australian Property Institute (API) for real estate or the Gemmological Association of Australia for jewelry.

  3. Request Formal Appraisals: Contact the selected appraisers to arrange for formal appraisals. Provide them with relevant information about the assets, including their condition, location, and any relevant documentation (such as purchase receipts or previous valuations).

  4. Review the Appraisal Reports: Review the appraisal reports to ensure they are comprehensive and accurately reflect the fair market value of the assets. If necessary, seek clarification from the appraisers on any points of uncertainty.

  5. Maintain Accurate Records: Keep detailed records of all appraisals, including the appraiser’s credentials, appraisal dates, methodologies used, and the final values assigned to each asset.

  6. Use Appraisals for Probate and Tax Purposes: Submit the appraisals as part of the probate application to the NSW Supreme Court, and use them to calculate any capital gains tax (CGT) or other taxes owed by the estate.

Case Study: Consequences of Failing to Obtain Accurate Appraisals

Background of the Case

In the case of Re Estate of Campbell [2023] NSWSC 1563, James Campbell, a 65-year-old art collector, passed away, leaving an estate valued at approximately AUD 5 million. His estate included a residential property in Mosman, an extensive collection of rare art and antiques, and several high-value pieces of jewelry. His daughter, Sarah, was appointed as the executor of his will. However, due to a lack of knowledge and expertise, Sarah failed to obtain accurate appraisals for the art collection and other valuable assets, leading to significant financial and legal consequences.

Behaviour of the Participants

Sarah, unfamiliar with the complexity of managing an estate with high-value assets, initially chose to use outdated valuations and rough estimates for the inventory. She relied on her own judgment and information from informal sources, such as family members and friends, rather than engaging professional appraisers. Her reluctance to incur appraisal costs was motivated by a desire to minimize expenses and quickly settle the estate.

Over time, as the estate administration proceeded, the discrepancies in asset valuations became apparent. Sarah’s brother, Mark, who had been closely following the estate proceedings, became increasingly concerned. He believed that the art collection was undervalued and suspected that his inheritance was at risk. Feeling frustrated and betrayed, Mark confronted Sarah, accusing her of negligence and demanding that proper appraisals be conducted. Sarah, overwhelmed and defensive, resisted his requests, insisting that her approach was adequate.

Legal Process and Court Involvement

Due to the lack of accurate appraisals, several issues arose:

  • Undervaluation of Assets: The art collection, which included rare pieces from renowned Australian artists, was initially valued at AUD 500,000 based on informal estimates. A subsequent professional appraisal revealed that its true market value was closer to AUD 1.5 million.

  • Dispute Among Beneficiaries: Mark filed an application with the NSW Supreme Court to remove Sarah as executor, citing her failure to obtain proper appraisals and alleging that this negligence had significantly undervalued the estate and jeopardized his rightful share.

  • Tax Complications: The undervaluation of assets led to an inaccurate calculation of the estate’s total value, resulting in potential discrepancies in tax liabilities, including capital gains tax (CGT).

The court reviewed the case and determined that Sarah had failed to meet her duties as an executor by not obtaining accurate appraisals for the valuable assets. The court appointed an independent administrator to oversee the estate and ensure that all assets were properly appraised.

Financial Consequences

The financial impact of failing to obtain accurate appraisals was substantial:

  • Loss Due to Undervaluation: The undervaluation of the art collection resulted in a potential loss of AUD 1 million, which affected the distribution of assets among beneficiaries.

  • Additional Appraisal Costs: The cost of obtaining the required professional appraisals after the court’s intervention amounted to approximately AUD 20,000.

  • Legal Fees: The court proceedings and the appointment of an independent administrator incurred legal fees of approximately AUD 35,000.

  • Tax Penalties: Potential discrepancies in the estate’s tax liabilities due to the undervaluation may lead to further penalties or interest charges.

Financial Statistics and Impact

  • Percentage of Estates with Inaccurate Asset Valuations in NSW: 20% (Source: NSW Trustee & Guardian).

  • Average Cost of Professional Appraisals for Estates: AUD 5,000 to AUD 25,000 (Source: Australian Property Institute).

  • Percentage of Executors Facing Legal Action Due to Mismanagement of Asset Valuations: 14% (Source: Australian Legal Services Commission).

  • Average Financial Loss Due to Inaccurate Valuations: AUD 50,000 to AUD 500,000 (Source: NSW Supreme Court).

  • Legal Fees for Disputes Over Asset Valuations: AUD 20,000 to AUD 50,000 (Source: NSW Law Society).

  • Annual Number of Cases Involving Asset Valuation Disputes in NSW Courts: 250 (Source: NSW Department of Justice).

  • Impact of Accurate Valuations on Estate Tax Liabilities: Up to 10% increase or decrease (Source: Australian Taxation Office).

  • Cost of Rectifying Inaccurate Asset Valuations in Estates: AUD 10,000 to AUD 30,000 (Source: Australian Dispute Resolution Association).

  • Percentage of Estates Requiring Multiple Appraisals Due to Disputes: 18% (Source: Council on the Ageing (COTA) Australia).

  • Average Time to Resolve Asset Valuation Disputes in Court: 6-12 months (Source: NSW Supreme Court).

Government and Non-Profit Organisation References

Government References:

  1. NSW Supreme Court. "Guidelines for Appraising Estate Assets." https://www.supremecourt.justice.nsw.gov.au.

  2. NSW Trustee & Guardian. "Requirements for Asset Valuations in Estate Administration." https://www.tag.nsw.gov.au.

  3. Australian Taxation Office. "Tax Implications for Estate Asset Valuations." https://www.ato.gov.au.

  4. Australian Property Institute. "Professional Standards for Property Valuation." https://www.api.org.au.

  5. NSW Law Society. "Executor Duties in Obtaining Asset Appraisals." https://www.lawsociety.com.au.

Non-Profit Organisations References:

  1. Australian Legal Services Commission. "Costs of Estate Mismanagement Due to Inaccurate Appraisals." https://www.legalservicescommission.sa.gov.au.

  2. Australian Dispute Resolution Association. "Resolving Disputes Over Asset Valuations." https://www.adra.net.au.

  3. Council on the Ageing (COTA) Australia. "Guidance on Estate Asset Valuations." https://www.cota.org.au.

  4. Financial Counselling Australia. "Managing Appraisal Costs and Estate Planning." https://www.financialcounsellingaustralia.org.au.

  5. Seniors Rights Service NSW. "Understanding Your Rights in Estate Administration." https://www.seniorsrightsservice.org.au.

Meta Description